Clinique Lash Power - anything as good (but cheaper)?

[Belo]

Clinique lash power is the only mascara I've found that doesn't smudge on me after a couple of hours. My current one needs replacing, but I'm on a tight budget this month and next (and probably one after tat too...). Has anybody found anything as good as it, but with a cheaper price tag?

I've tried op I really have but have not had luck with cheaper tubing mascara alternatives. I tried the superdrug one and it flaked a bit, I've also tried others maybe loreal and dolly wink. I'm currently using the Kevin Aucoin one which is as good and does a longer lash but that's even dearer but overall, lash power has the best staying power and will be the next one I buy. Will watch with interest though as surely a decent dupe must be out there.

Which superdrug one did you buy? There are three tubing ones and they are all half price at the moment on the website. I've just ordered one of each to try out as I love tubing mascaras.
B. Longer Lengthening & Defining Mascara
B. All Lengthening Defining Volumising Mascara
B. Loud High Volume Mascara

I got the B longer. It's a good mascara and I liked the packaging too. But I didn't find it as good as lash power, though I know it has lots of fans on here.

I have issues with mascara giving me panda eyes too. I use Bourgois Volume Clubbing Mascara and it doesn't budge and I love the results. A lot cheaper than clinique too.

GOSH also does a tubing mascara.

I found Bourjois Volume Clubbing difficult to remove and quite drying.

L'Oreal has a tubing mascara too, it is the double ended one in the red and white packaging. I prefer just using the mascara, not a massive fan of the primer bit.

I've never heard of 'tubing mascaras' before. I've just googled it. I didn't realise that's what Lash Power was!

Now I know what I'm looking for it may be easier to find I'll go in hint of the L'Oreal / Bourjois one tomorrow. Thank you!