Help me choose a new coat!

[Silvertap]

After losing all my babyweight I'm being treated to a new winter coat. I've narrowed it down to these@
www.barbour.com/uk/all-collections/womens/waterproof-jackets/b-intl-reflector-jacket/p/LWB0351NY7110?breadcrumbs=womens&breadcrumbs=womens-waterproofjackets
www.barbour.com/uk/all-collections/womens/waterproof-jackets/barbour-deck-coat/p/LWB0302NY7110?breadcrumbs=womens&breadcrumbs=womens-waterproofjackets
www.barbour.com/uk/all-collections/womens/waterproof-jackets/barbour-kirkby-coat/p/LWB0352NY7110
www.seasaltcornwall.co.uk/women/clothing/casual-jackets-in-soft-cord-and-printed-cotton/tiller-short-warm-fleece-lined-raincoat_galley.htm

Does anyone have any of the above or have something similar they'd recommend?

Number one or number 3 both barbour. Really dont like the sea salt number, sorry.

Don't be sorry about not liking sea salt! My heart is with a Barbour one - it's what I was thinking of but j just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing anything from any other brand.

I would go for the Kirkby.

I like the first one the best by far.

Well done on loosing your baby weight!

Thanks bluebiscuits. I'm quite proud of myself - 4 stone off twice as I've had 2 kids.

Sorry, that sounded completely up myself didn't it! My dad promised me a Barbour if I could keep the weight off - he blatantly didn't think he'd have to put his money where his mouth is!

1st one by a country mile. Well done!

I like the first and the third but the secpnd one isnt very long so probably the first.

Sorry like the first and the second.