Opinions on these boots please

[macnab]

I think I like these Clarks boots

Would it be ok to wear them with skinny jeans tucked in?

Or are these nicer?

I think the new look ones would look better with skinnies, dont care for the first ones sorry. Look abit mum boot to me

First pair are much more practical for winter, as suede doesn't do that well in rain/sleet/snow/storms. Clarks are also likely to be far better quality.

Yes I think you could wear those with skinny jeans tucked in, but you could also cuff them just above top of boot.

I kind of agree with above poster on style, though. If we're talking style alone I would probably go for b).

yes, the suede does put me off a bit. I'm 41 but still prefer style over substance though!

Any recommendations for something like the second pair but in leather as opposed to suede?

I really dont like the way the tow curls up on the first pair. I prefer the look of the second pair but I wouldnt expect much from new look in the way of comfort.

I wearing the first pair now. I've had a good few compliments about them and they are sooooo comfy.

I think the first pair are nice enough that you can un-mum boot them. If you like the look of them I'd say go for it. They'll last well and be comfortable plus they're practical.

New look ones are much nicer

Toe, not tow!
Mortified.

I think the second pair are bland and will end up grubby in no time.

Much prefer the second pair, but I doubt they will be as comfy or last as long as the Clarkes ones

I got these a few weeks ago which are similar to the new look pair but leather. Lovely and comfy and look good with skinnies

www.dunelondon.com/mobile/pollie-western-style-heeled-leather-ankle-boot-0092506690013511/