Which of these jumpers?

[Greengardenpixie]

www.toa.st/uk/product/womens+knitwear/CAEBK/Maxi+Must+Tunic.htm?categoryref=%2fcategory.aspx%3fcategoryid%3dwomens%2520knitwear%26seoterm%3dknitwear%26&pcat=womens+knitwear&adimage=&clr=CAEBK_Loganberry

or

www.toa.st/uk/product/womens+dresses/C1EBC/Shetland+Stripe+Neat+Dress.htm?categoryref=%2fcategory.aspx%3fcategoryid%3dwomens%2520dresses%26seoterm%3ddresses%26&pcat=womens+dresses&adimage=&clr=C1EBC_BrandyMarlinMariner

Dont look at the model on the second one. I have sized up so its nice and baggy. I love both but cannot afford to keep both.

I do have a jumper in the purply colour but this one is oversized so not the same style.

Which one shall i keep?

I like the second one more!

First one for me.

One a piece..ha ha hence my dilema!
Anyone else?

First one!

I think if you are gong for an oversized look, then the first one, not sure how the pattern would work if too baggy. (Like how it looks fitted, that is the second jumper)

First one

First one for me!

I love the stripey second one, but can't imagine it baggy. So I think if you want baggy, then the purple one.

Its not that baggy, just a bit looser. I really like the shape of the first one. I dont like the tight look on the model when its fitted but love the print of the first one.
Maybe its a bit shapeless looser? I will try on again tomorrow.

I may keep the first one and buy the stripey one at sale time! Sadly, think the stripey one may sell out quicker as its more unusual?

I like both but would pick the second one

The second one.

You could post headless pics of yourself in both of them?

stripey one!
does the bottom not go baggy when you have been sitting down in these knit dresses? ( I mean where your bottom is,not the bottom hem)

First one but in petrol or grey not purple.

Stripey one is awful.

Second one is bloody awful a bit mismatched and lairy for me.

I like the first one in all the colourways.

First one.

The second looks like the numerous brightly coloured knitted dresses that come with matching stripey tights for toddler girls. Not a great look on an adult imo.

Decided to keep the purple one. Love the colour and the shape better. Its also lovely and soft. The other one is a tiny bit itchy. Thanks everyone.

Correct choice

Really though, it's a lovely purple. Really rich and deep.

1
I think 2 is ugly

I agree with 1) That dark purple is one of my favourite colours.
I do have a sneaky liking for 2) but I think it might make your boobs look humungous.

Hope you enjoy wearing it. I have a merino tunicy thing from Toast that's still going strong after about 8 years