Please help me decide which boots?

[Dancergirl]

Sorry, also posted on the which boots thread...but I need the MN verdict on which boots to keep. I currently have both pairs at home and need to return one.

Pair 1 from Dune:

www.dunelondon.com/peggy-double-buckle-leather-calf-boot-0863506030004484/

Pair 2 from Boden:

www.boden.co.uk/en-GB/Womens-Shoes-Boots/Boots/AZ225/Womens-Smithfield-Boot.html

Both in black. Ideally I want them to wear with dresses rather than jeans or trousers.

If it's more pretty dresses, I'd go for Boden ones. If it's more Jersey fitted dresses/tunics and leggings, I'd go for the biker ones

It's the latter, tunics, knitted dresses etc.

I love the Dune ones but think the Boden ones are meh.

Yes I think the Boden ones don't really work.

The Dune ones are very nice, but have now also seen some slightly taller ones from Frye courtesy of a MNer on other other boots thread!

Dune ones definitely
I like my biker boots though and wear them with tunics and knitted dresses.
Do not like the Boden ones at all - sorry.

I have these ones although mine are slightly shorter than that.