Anyone tried Nars Larger Than Life eyeliner?

[Aquamarine70]

It seems to have good reviews. I'm looking for one that I can sharpen & doesn't smudge under the eye after a few hours wear.

yes I have lots but haven't used for a while. They come with a mini sharpener. I have oily skin and watery eyes and they last better than other pencils I've used. But, they do end up smudging :-( So I've given up on them for a while. Prefer Seventeen's Tattoo Me but miss the lovely range of shades Larger Than Life do. My favourite is a forest green. They are fine on me for an evening but not for a whole day, at least not under the eye, which is annoying
White one is fantastic for inner corners and stays put the best, even on me

(Tattoo Me is liquid and I use on waterline, bottom. Lasts a few hours on me which is more than anything else does). but there's only two shades

They last fine on me, I do get minor smudging at the end of the night but better than most. I find better results if I use it with the eye make up base by Nars as well. And the sharpener is a bit fiddly.