I'm a big fan of 90's grunge style and have been searching for some chunky loafer-type shoes for ages. I had some at school which I loved and wore to death! Finally, I've found two styles I like on ASOS, which do you think are better?
I'd wear them with skater skirts, black tights, tshirts and polo shirts, with an oversized denim/ bomber or leather jacket. Also with dresses for work.
Votes please? 
Shoe1
Shoe2