Help me replace my eye liner

[Cabbagesaregreen]

Years ago someone recommended Estée Lauder double wear in graphite - I think it was cod. It's fantastic.
For some stupid reason they've stopped making this colour.

What can I replace it with? I love the colour and everything about it.

Sorry I don't know that one, but I completely love the Bobbi Brown gel defined liner. Like a pencil but much smoother and no need for sharpener.

The Laura mercier block one is superb

I have ysl liner in graphite. It's very good.

Theanks for suggestions. Will try them.