Eyeliner not pen/pencil type.

[Greenteandchives]

Hi can anyone help me find a cake eyeliner, as in the type that is painted on with a wet brush? I know about Lauren Mercier Tightliner, but the colours are not what I am looking for. I would like a charcoal grey if possible.
I currently use a dark grey powder eyeshadow, but it lacks staying power.
Any help gratefully received!

YSL do a lovely grey liquid eyeliner in a tube with a very fine brush. Not the cake-type you are looking for but I think it is a fabulous product . Long lasting and subtle look, gives definition without looking harsh .

I've just bought a Soap and Glory one which I'm really happy with. I also have an Estée Lauder one - that's available in a few more colours.

Have a look at Stila - also not a cake one but has a very fine brush and comes in 15 shades including grey. Some colours currently half price on their website.

Thanks I will have a look at all of these.

Bobbi brown do gel eyeliner in a pot, it's really good IMO.

I have tried gel, but can't get on with it at all! Thanks anyway.