Urban decay 24/7 eyeliner - brown shade?

[DaftSkunk]

I've been trying to find an eyeliner with some staying power for tightlining and UB's seems to get good reviews. I need a brown as black looks to harsh - I'm planning to order online and I can't tell the difference between the brown shades easily - I don't want a glittery one. Can anyone help please?

Thanks!

Urgh sorry.. too harsh

I got Whiskey free with the naked palette and that's a plain brown.

For tight lining I actually use loreal infallible liner pencil in coffee which I love.

What's tight lining?

Fear not, I asked the Google.

Thanks cheesy, do you find the loreal lasts? If so I might give that a go!

Yes it does. It also comes with a smudger thing one one end so I put a bit on my top lash line too. I now wear this look during the day instead of liquid liner which can look harsh with my pale colouring.

I adore the Urban Decay eyeliners, though I have all the green shades, not brown.

My absolute favourite shade they do is called mildew

Mildew! That's an interesting name..! Off to google