Can't decide on these 2 hairstyles. What do you think (AKA please help!)

[LadySybilLikesSloeGin]

Oval face, fine brown hair. It's shoulder length at the moment and I have an appointment next week.

Many thanks

The first one. I had that style and loved it!

Yes to the 2nd Pinterest one too.

I really like the second pinterest one. Checked and it doesn't look like ds's hairstyle :D

Thank you, think I might go for it. It grows quickly so won't take too long to fix if it looks terrible

Thank you for all your help, you're all fab

I like the 3rd (blonde) one. I also love a pixie cut, My cousin one a bit shorter than the pic and she has an oval face.

This one? a lot a bit of salt spray should do it, I think

That one the Carey Mulligan one is the nicest of all the styles you have put up. All the styles were nice but to me that is the stand out one.

Oh, think that's the one!

be wary of a pixie cut op if you have fast growing hair

i have had 3 or 4 versions of said cut and sometimes it has grown out of shape in literally days

OP, what does salt spray do?

Makes it look sea swept, gives the layers a bit more definition.

Maybe a pixie is a bad move I think a bob in the hope that I can make it a shaggy bob is a bad move too. I tried scrunching it when it was wet last night and that did absolutely naff all. Back to the drawing board

The Carey is lovely.

And it's not what I'd call a pixie.

I always think of pixies as a bit frumpy. Where I live, as soon as women hit 45 they all seem to get the same cropped haircut.

I like the Carey one and the first one in your very first post. Much more modern.

I like the Carey one too, its not a pixie though. Not short enough.

Oh, I'm confused! It's really fine (there's a lot of it though so I'm not bald), it doesn't wave, it doesn't curl and it knots if it's long and I try to leave it down, and it's quick growing. I've had a bob and it doesn't curl underneath so goes flat and looks dull. Argh!

I'm a bit confused, you say you don't want a bob but two of the first pics are bobs.

Yup. I don't think I have a choice. Farking hair seems to like dull bobs I don't know what else to do with it.