which coat?

[Jewels234]

In coat shopping hell at the moment. I hate that oversized trend, but finding there's not a huge amount else out there.

So, after opinions. Which coat? I'm a size 10, 5 ft 4, get bored of coats each year so tend to buy a new one every year...
m.houseoffraser.co.uk/Whistles+Holly+longline+overcoat/205515183,default,pd.html

m.johnlewis.com/mt/www.johnlewis.com/store/collection-by-john-lewis-longline-coat/p1671192?colour=Navy&un_jtt_v_dummy=yes#page_loaded

Of those two, I much, much prefer the more traditional john Lewis coat.

I am the same height and size as you and never find that those long coats do anything for me. I have to go a bit shorter. How do you find they fit?

Amazing, I think so too, thanks!

Haven't tried either on...have bought both online and will return one.

Love the John lewis one