An unrecommendation - Garnier

[hollyisalovelyname]

I recommended the Garnier eye make up remover for sensitive eyes, praising it to the skies. It came in a green, then blue, bottle.
Sadly, they appear to have changed the formulation- now in a purple bottle and has caused a bad reaction around my eyes.
Grrrr- if it's not broken why fix it?

Same here! I loved the the blue bottle but the new formula makes me spotty ..wasting money trying find a new cleanser now .

Is this the blue bottle with the oil and water mix? Noooooo they just can't change it, it's perfect as it was.

No it was the sensitive eye make up remover. It WAS super. Non irritating.
NOT ANYMORE

i love the one that you mix - the oil and water one marylou mentioned. Ive just bought it today. It takes off my waterproof mascara beautifully.

I don't think the Garnier biphase one works as well as it used to. It doesn't swipe everything off any more and I don't even use waterproof mascara. Any recs for an alternative? The Nivea biphase was useless and irritating.