Shapeless sack or simple chic office dress?

[Behoove]

For a busty size 16, to wear with thick tights and long boots in winter.

here

Looks a bit sacky to me, sorry!

I'm in the shapeless sack camp I'm afraid, sorry.

Very shapeless sack, especially on someone busty. Sorry.

I suspected that would be the case. Thanks.

A second option here ?

Not sure about the asymmetry on the white bit in the second one,

what about something like this www.asos.com/ASOS-Curve/ASOS-CURVE-Wrap-Dress-With-Bow-Front-In-Longer-Length/Prod/pgeproduct.aspx?iid=4364816&cid=9577&Rf900=1465&sh=0&pge=1&pgesize=36&sort=-1&clr=Black&totalstyles=316&gridsize=3

Thanks super
Would you believe it, I have that one already!

Ideally what im looking for is a thick ponte or jersey zip or button through shirt dress with sleeves and a decent length. If such a thing exists.

Second option is nice enough. The first is a sack.

Something like THIS??
PONTE??
Flattering?

Thanks hells I really 'like the roman originals dress, will have a good look again on that site.

Well I think the first one is much much nicer than any of the others!

dreadful. flares out at all the wrong places. Hattie Jacques comes to mind.

I am wearing that in black today behoove
It's very flattering. Hides my tummy nicely.
I've just ordered the same dress I have linked and one in black with white spots.
Comfy as well.
Everyone comments when I wear it.
Hope they all like the other versions as well!

This ? m.newlook.com/application/product/view?cat=326718150

Going against the grain but that would work well on my figure (Apple shaped, no defined waist). If you have a good waist avoid that style though.

I love the ponte dress in forest green, it's stunning.

The wrap or bias ruched dresses look good. The first one is ghastly. That model looks like she's going to throw ashes on herself and start tearing out her hair.