Which YSL clutch please???

[HappyGirlNow]

Help! Looking to purchase a YSL clutch to do me many years and not sure which of these I should get? Admittedly there's not much in it - one's squarer and ones more rectangular - but which would you pick and why?

m.selfridges.com/mt/www.selfridges.com/en/Bags/Categories/Shop-Women/Clutches-evening-bags/Monogramme-envelope-clutch_118-2000644-348311C15011000/?previewAttribute=Noir

Or

m.selfridges.com/mt/www.selfridges.com/en/Bags/Categories/Shop-Women/Clutches-evening-bags/Monogramme-envelope-clutch_118-2000644-348311C15011000/?previewAttribute=Noir

LTB, seriously!

Ltb.

Rofl. Definitely LTB

Oops second link should be this

m.selfridges.com/mt/www.selfridges.com/en/Bags/Categories/Shop-Women/Clutches-evening-bags/Cassandre-quilted-leather-clutch_118-2000644-332643B0F011000/?previewAttribute=Black

Do come back when you have a relationship problem, won't you?

Oh god doing well!!! Thought I was in Style and Beauty!!!

Ok after I've LTB, which bag should I get??

Ooops!

First one definitely. Also LTB. Also, tell us if S and B agree.

I have a clutch for an '02 Astra in my garage you can try. It's like new.

Second one, no contest.
LTB (leave the bag) and keep the clutch.

The first one. I would ltso.

Who is paying for the bag?
Are you feeling the need to lie about the price to your partner?

Definitely LTB, but only after purchasing the bag. I hope it's not considered marital assets.

Prefer the square one, but find the massive logo kind of horrible tbh. But I guess if you are paying £900 pound for a brand you might want to see it

also LTB

Haha fabby all, thank you

dont LTB, its not his fault. I'd blame yr parents.

I also prefer the first one (first ones?).

Aw I was all excited to spend someone else's money but I don't like either .

They're just boring and dated looking clutches with a really obnoxious logo.

I am no bag lady (arf) but surely for the best part of a grand you can find something insanely gorgeous?!

Thanks all

More subtle logo???

m.selfridges.com/mt/www.selfridges.com/en/Bags/Categories/Shop-Women/Clutches-evening-bags/Chyc-leather-clutch_485-2000644-311213BJ50J1000/?previewAttribute=Noir.

Sorry running with this!

Last one, last one!

As the claws are out, you should get this.

We had to have some kitten pictures.

Ooh smashing Lweji

What about ivory??

m.selfridges.com/mt/www.selfridges.com/en/Bags/Categories/Shop-Women/Clutches-evening-bags/Chyc-leather-clutch_118-2000644-311213BJ50J9007/?previewAttribute=Chalk

Ivory gets dirtier sooner.

Do we have an outfit for it to go with or is is a day to day bag?

The third one is miles better than the other two, but I still don't think it's worth the money. I would want some serious Wow for that sort of money.

Have they got any with white metal clasps?

That cat one is brilliantly awful .

I don't have claws out for you OP. I have absolutely no objection to people buying lovely things - I love it in fact!

I just think there must be more lovely to be had than these bags!