Eyeliner recommendations

[HaymitchAbarnathy]

Hi wondered if anyone had any recommendations for cheap to mid price eyeliners? I used to use rimmel gel eyeliner but they seem to have discontinued it, I tried the mua one which is similar but it was too dry and draggy. I've been wearing rimmel thick and thin scandal eyes one which goes on well but doesn't last. It's my first try with a felt too style one and I quite like how it applies but need something that won't disappear by the end of the day!
I'm happy to spend up to about a tenner, and I don't like pencils
Tia!

A felt tip style that should say

Maybelline do a great gel eyeliner

I have tried the maybelline one and didn't get on with it, which was I moved over to the rimmel one. Thank you though!

I was going to recommend the Maybelline gel liner too, the brush it comes with isn't great but the product its self is fab.

Ah, Rimmel seem to have a 'new' gel liner, that might explain things...

Ah! I hadn't seen that - will keep it in mind, I think I want a felt tip that stays on though!

smashbox one is great

L'Oreal superliner is really good.

This triple tip one from Bourjois that you 'dot' along the lashes is apparently really good and only £7.

I got the gel eyeliner from Avon as a Christmas present and it's really good. Lasts forever. Don't know how much it costs, but it's Avon so shouldn't be too much

Thank you, am going to check out bourgeois and the super liner too - loving style and beauty for make up recommendations at the moment!

I got the Boots 17 gel liner recently. The brush with it is naff so I am off tomorrow to get another one (brush that is). Seems to last on me and my eyes constantly water anyway.

I love the soap and glory felt pen style one, called Cat Eye or something. I was never brilliant at applying gel style ones and I can't seem to get this one wrong.
I think it lasts well, only wears off in the evening when I start rubbing my eyes.