Winter coat

[loopydoo]

What do you to either of these?
I'm pear shaped with big bum/thighs so want a longer style this year to cover everything up but to also be warm.

I have a formal black wool coat so I want something more outdoorsy....

www.gooutdoors.co.uk/sprayway-siri-gore-tex-jacket-p266876

or

www.gooutdoors.co.uk/craghoppers-nariko-jacket-p213350

tbh - I prefer price of second but looks of first.

what do people think ?

I think it depends on how much you would wear it if you were worried about cost.

I think the first is my proffered choice

The first one is nice as far as waterproof goes,I'm pleasantly surprised!

I don't like the second one.

Thank you .
Yes - had a closer look at the second and it's a bit drab.