I'm thinking if trying this. Most cheap & even expensive mascaras smudge or flake on me. Lancôme Definicils is the only one that doesn't. I have eyelash extensions but I'm going to stop as my lashes are short or have been pulled out. I'm going to put grow lash serum on them. I bought Clinique bottom lash, thought it was ok but it has dried out after a few uses & flakes. I like separation & a little bit of volume.