This is a waterfall card isn't it?

[naturelover]

East

The thing is, it suits me, and I think it looks nice. I'm 38, tall and slim and would wear it with skinny jeans and boots, scarf or chunky necklace.

But I've kept the receipt and I may return it or give it to my mum.

What's the MN verdict?

FWIW I really like it... waterfall cardi to me tends to be like the ones my mum wears from M & S which are much longer at the back than the front. Keep it, it's nice - what colour did you get?

I like it.

I bought grey. To replace an old Phase Eight cardi that has seen better days. Thanks for the vote of confidence!

It's also a huge bargain for merino.

Have considered it myself.
Have had 2 East cardigans this winter,both reduced and lovely quality,go for it!

I really like it.

It's very nice and a bargain!

I love it and fantastic price for 100% wool. I buy from wherever, if I like the garment I like the garment regardless of which shop it's from.......I'm sure it will look amazing worn with the right things.

I like it, keep it.

You are tall and slim.... You will look gorgeous. I think it's lovely anyway but it's only on shorter and curvy people like me that I think they can look frumpy.

That's lovely, gorgeous colour and a complete steal for wool too. I would also wear it like you say, am also tall & slim.

Sort of, yes. But that's necessarily a bad thing. Remember lots of people on MN are about 12 and have tattoos and live in skinny jeans and Uggs so their opinions should not necessarily be heeded.

It is nice, useful and a bit boring.

I meant that's NOT necessarily a bad thing

What are their sizes like? I am an 18 - 20 - will I get away with an XL or does XL mean size 14?

Lovely....it's more structured than a "real" waterfall cardi....which tend to floop and flap at the front far more.

Nice, was eyeing it myself today! I'd wear it with a skinny belt too over a dress.

IamLouisWalsh re sizing, I'm a 10-12 with broadish shoulders and the Medium fits well.

I think it's frumpy ..sorry

I have no tattoos ...honestly

I quite like..I am six feet tall so it may look ok

East is a funny shop. We have a big one here, and it's full of crinkly blouses and lots of jewellery.
Who is it aimed at? I see lots of 60 somethings in there.

It's an old person cardigan trying to be trendy (and failing)

It looks amazingly useful, sadly I'm too short.