Coloured eyeliner

[AuntySib]

Is it completley wrong? In all circumstances? I don't want to chuck them all out but feel I should.

no, why should you?

No, not at all. I often wear navy/khaki gel liner.

Why on earth would it be? Surely they're all coloured?

No, I think browns or khaki shades are often a lot more flatting. Black eyeliner really doesn't work for all/most people.

Nope. I would be so bored without them - mainly use pale grey with coloured liners (purple, green, dark teal) and matching mascara when I can find it. Didn't realise I was doing anything wrong!?!

I'm thinking blues/greens. Interesting that you all think its fine. Should add am over 40, don't want a mutton effect, but find black too harsh, and normally wear brown, but just occasionally fancy a change.