Benefit They're Real Mascara does it smudge?

[tabbycat15]

I normally use Definicils by Lancôme & it doesn't smudge & is easy to remove. I just fancy trying something else. Is it easy to remove?

not sure, but I usually use Lancôme hypnôse, and recently changed to Dior New Look. It is fab, proper individual lashes, doesn't' smudge, and stays put until I remove it with eye make up remover. I do find i need two coats to get fuller lashes, but I love the way it doesn't clump or go on too thickly and gives a more natural look.

Dunno but Estee Lauder Doublewear never smudges and I'm a shocking eye-rubber.

I use they're real, and no it doesn't smudge during the day. In fact the best mascara EVER!

I bought this last week. It's shit. Complete shit. Don't waste your ££.

No volume. Just thin, spindly lashes. Utter shite.

I'm sticking to Max Factor 2000 Calories. When I wear it someone always asks if I have falsies on Amazing stuff.

And half the price

I love it for the first couple of weeks, and then the tube seems to start to dry out and it's a bit clumpy. Doesn't smudge, easy to remove with a proper make up remover, or cream cleanser.

Revlon Grow Luscious is also a really good cheaper alternative.

I'm finding it a bit clumpy too

Mine is going on Ebay.

£19 my arse

I didn't think it was very good. I prefer the Benefit Bad Gal mascara. It makes my eyelashes look much thicker.

Its rubbish imo. I use L'Oreal Million and that is ace. They're Real doesn't smudge but its really hard to remove and it makes my eyes sore. On the other hand my sister who works for Benefit says its brilliant and it will be joining High beam, Boiing, and Bad Gal classics. So people are buying it.

I like how it looks but can't take it off. There is an offer on at Boots for a £10 mini.

It smudged loads on me, but then lots of Mascara does

May have to try Double wear...

I've been using it around four months and not had any smudging issues.

Thanks all, I'll have a look at the Dior one. I had heard that Thery're Real dries out after a while. Definicils doesn't dry. I like their Cils booster underneath as it gives more volume.

Lamcome doll eyes doesn't

I've never had an issue with smudging, drying out or clumping [bconfused]

I love it!

I quite like it but do find it can leave a bit of a smudge sometimes (most mascaras do on my skin!) I also find it dries a bit after a few weeks. It is pretty good but not the best and not for the price tag.