Coat A or coat B?

[ChoccyJules]

I have tried this on in the shop and it fits well, no gaping chest and gives me a shape www.johnlewis.com/335830/Product.aspx

But today there is a flash sale and this one is reduced to same price: www.johnlewis.com/356826/Product.aspx

Trendier? But will they size trendy, ie will the 18 be tight I wonder?

Any chance anyone owns either of these? And does the belt look nicer than the zip?

Don't really like either (sorry) second is much better than first & would say the sizing would be the same as it's a brand aimed at the more mature woman

The Planet ones looks much nicer on the website than the other one, as to how it will fit?????????

B is for best.

I prefer the second one. I also like the first one in stone colour.
But have not seen either in RL.

I like the Planet coat best.

www.johnlewis.com/366974/Product.aspx

This one is similar but nicer.