Help me choose between two coats

[Birdies]

This one:

www.zara.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product/uk/en/zara-neu-W2012/269183/827340/PUFFER%20JACKET%20WITH%20FUR%20HOOD

And this one:

www.marksandspencer.com/Per-Una-Funnel-Neck-Duffle/dp/B003ZHG3LU?ie=UTF8&ref=sr_1_11&nodeId=43014030&sr=1-11&qid=1350672494&pf_rd_r=06JSZVM928KN7VWKHVW6&pf_rd_m=A2BO0OYVBKIQJM&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_i=43014030&pf_rd_p=321381387&pf_rd_s=related-items-3

Thanks!

Zara one - I don't like the M&S one at all.

I'm NOT liking the Markies one at all. Looks very odd. Not really loving the Zara one either though, so you should probably just ignore me,

The Zara one, definitely!

Zara!!!

Is it just cos per una is a bit sad though compared to Zara?

Zara, but I don't really like it. The m&s one is weird.

this is m&s one is a bit better

I did try this one as well but it looked horrendous. On me anyway. Bit like I'd taken DH's suit jacket and slapped a bit of leather on the front. But it's fashionable I think!

www.zara.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product/uk/en/zara-neu-W2012/269183/995025/LEATHER%20BIKER%20COAT

The zara puffer one is really flattering though, I was surprised. Haven't tried the m&s one yet but I like the look of it

What about this?

I quite like that one too but prefer a longer one (to cover the arse!)

hmmm, zara one is a bit boring imo
per una one looks kind of odd, but I'd be tempted to try it on in the shop

The weird leathery one is odd. I like the zara puffer one. Nothing wrong with a boring coat imho!

Zara puffa is ok, I bought one 2 years ago, the awful winter. There was no heat in it at all, I gave it away last year.

I quite like the weird leathery one. Fancied it for myself!

Zara better than the M&S one

I definitely like the Zara one and definitely don't like the M&S one and I've had the odd nice thing from Per Una before now