Is the Revlon Just Bitten Balm Stain a good economy version of the Clinique Chubby Stick?

[StBoniface]

I've just seen these in a magazine www.boots.com/en/Revlon-Just-Bitten-trade-Lipstain-Balm_1208067/ and thought they look just like the Clinique Chubby Sticks, are they similar?

They look really similar and are a lot cheaper, anyone tried one?

I have the chubby stick but think after trying these on my hand that they leave more of a stain i.e. they are long-lasting in comparison

The Revlon are longer lasting?

Yes, IMO

Excellent, I'll buy one then, just need to decide which shade to try. I'll see if they have them in my local Boots to have a good look at the colours, it hard to tell online. Thanks

I have one, they are really nice. Easy to use and mine smells all minty! I got the colour honey which is a soft mauvey pink. It lasted a long time (few hours) and was moisturising unlike most lip tints which suck out every drop of oil in there.
I'd definately get another and reccomend it.

I much prefer them to the Chubby Sticks. I was really disappointed in those. Nice and moisturising, but hardly any colour pay-off and don't last long. Just a slightly tinted lip balm really. The Revlon ones are brilliant. Softer and smoother to apply, really pigmented and actually stain the lips without drying them, lasting ages.

They look the same, but are completely different.

I've got one and I think it's rubbish.

Doesn't stay on long at all.

Maybe I just have odd lips!

It's also got 2 quid off op in Boots making it only 5.99