Help me decide oh wise S&B ones!

[punkin]

dh gave me a mulberry bayswater bag for my birthday, I have always wanted this bag so am over the moon but I thought I always wanted it in oak and he got it in the black.

I can exchange it for the oak but I am kind of liking the black now...which do you like better and do you think I will get more use out of the black?

Thank you!

I'd get the oak but thats just because I find the hardware a bit jarring against he black, if they did silver hardware on the black it would be no contest. Also tan is better for all seasons IMO.

thanks for answering - I think you are right about the tan being better for all seasons.

I would get the oak too, even though it's more delicate than the black. It goes with everything