Having tried probably nearly a hundred mascaras (god, I think this could actually be completely true), I have found the Best (so far). I had thought that YSL Faux Cils Volume and the Model Co Brush on False lashes were unbeatable but, shock horror, today via a friend I splurged........ £4.... No 17 Peep Show mascara in Brown Black. Literally, it is fantastic. NO smudging, Great defenition, has lasted all day and I just love it. Had to share it with you, and need to now get onto other threads to see where my savings can be spent, if my mascara budget is now £4!!!!!!