Barbour or Joules..spring jacket

[MedusaIsHavingABadHairDay]

I'd like a lightweight quilted jacket for spring, and really like the ones that everyone seems to be wearing at the moment. I have narrowed it down to either a shaped Barbour Lidlesdale or Joules ..EITHER the shorter Hampton or the Moredale. I'm a size 10.. 5 ft 6 skinny middle but quite broad shoulders and wondered if anyone has experience of the fit?

I need help to decide which to get please!!

links?

www.barbourbymail.co.uk/Womens-Barbour-Tartan-Shaped-Liddesdale-Quilted.html

www.joules.com/en-GB/Womens-Quilted-Jacket/Navy/M_HAMPTON/ProductDetail.raction

www.joules.com/en-GB/Womens-Quilted-Jacket/Navy/M_HAMPTON/ProductDetail.raction

I have a couple of Jules jackets/coats and I too have broad shoulders and find bought 12 to allow for them and they fit very well.My barbour is a proper old tatty hardcore one so no help there really.

I have the shaped Barbour Liddesdale and I love it but it is very 'equestrian', unlike the joules ones which normally seem more casual. The fit is very generous in my opinion, and the length is great, bum-covering on me and I'm 5'5". Hope that helps!