Which tunic-y dress do you think?

[flybynight]

This one here - silk and colourful. Or this one here. More muted, with good sleeves but man made fibres?

To be worn with leggings and flats probably.

The Zara one is much nicer, IMHO. But as you say, it would depend rather a lot on the fabric.

I prefer the Zara one (but I am an old gimmer!)

oh me too! Should have mentioned that

I love the Warehouse one! If you look good in yellow like that model then I am very jealous of you.

I don't like either!

I prefer the Zara one but more because I look rubbish in yellow.

Zara. the warehouse one looks a bit cheap.

I don't have a problem wearing any colour really - yellow is fine. I think the Zara wins for its sleeves, though. I also think the Warehouse one would be a bit thin and cheap looking. I thank you for your opinions. Very much.

I prefer the Zara one but I also love this Warehouse tunic

www.johnlewis.com/314714/Product.aspx

It depends on your colouring - blonde/dark/fair skinned etc.

I like the Zara dress.

I think the Warehouse dress is nasty. I hate the shape, pattern, and the unflattering cut-off arms. I can't imagine anyone looking good in it.

Sorry to be blunt.

They're both a bit cheap-looking for the price, but ain't that just the way these days.

both horrible, sorry!

Zara one by a mile.

Yikes to both. Wearhouse one is too startling in colour and pattern and the Zara one looks like a dust bunny under a microscope is too drab.

Hmm. Total rethink then. Bugger.