Eyeliner/smokey eyes pencil that stays put?

[saythatagain]

I've seen several women with that natural look - with gentle brown-beigh tones and then a 'just right' amount of smudging above and below the eye. I know how to apply and acjeive it but I can't the correct smudging pencil where it stays put and doesn't me panda/black eye/bags under the eye look. Any suggestions? Ta.

Another vote for MAC eyeliners!

mac khol liner pencil works well for me and stay put
am gonna try the EL doublewear now as well though.

Another vote for BB gel liners. They are genius - absolutely no budging, but just the right amount of smudging possible before they 'stick'!

love the EL doublewear one (I use graphite) for smudgy look

Urban Decay 24/7 ones are also great - very smooth to apply, then you can smudge before they set if you want. Amazing colour range and they last longer than the EL one on me.