I agree with you on both parts actually.
Child maintenance calculations make little to no sense. And, sometimes, I wonder if the higher calculations aren’t doing the ex more harm than good. It’s another way that women end up not increasing their own earning potential because they can be dependent on a man’s income. It’s a precarious way to live, and in the long term it leaves women in dreadful situations.
Obviously I have no issue with sharing the costs of children and making sure they’re fine. Indeed, I receive child maintenance myself. So I really am not some weird MRA type here.
It’s more that in some situations, the higher maintenance payments genuinely aren’t paying for the children. The excess well beyond the costs of the children are propping up an ex who is choosing not to work. My concern there is actually that the woman ends up financially screwed once the kids grow up (especially if there’s also a mesher order on the house) rather than anything about the cost to the NRP.
As a SM, none of the maintenance stuff would be my concern really (DH’s contribution to the family pot is what makes it to the joint account after all deductions, and l give no more thought to the maintenance than his pension contributions), but I can foresee his ex (who is absolutely determined that she will not work - she’s clearly too good for that - and wants the world to pay for her) behaving absolutely abhorrently once the writing is on the wall and the child maintenance is coming to an end.
Genuinely, some kind of child support system that helped to ensure that she could afford to retrain/renew her qualifications and build a career. and supported her while childcare payments to do that and to work (plus the actual costs of having the kids slightly more than DH does) would be much better for her in the longer term. I can’t imagine it being cheaper for DH either (probably more expensive, as childcare is so expensive). But his ex would utterly hate it.
Now there’s a point of view that will go down like a lead balloon. But, again, I’m not worrying about the costs to NRPs. I actually think systems should encourage people to become independent and self sufficient as much as possible. It’s not good being at all financially dependent on your ex (especially where the relationship is hostile).