Which Sophie to buy there two versions

[TinkerPony]

Hi have Xmas voucher. Looking for feedback experiences for the Sophie griafe teething product I was aware of the speak teething toy and now I'm I store and see there a teething ring too.
Not require yet not teething yet but like to be prepared.
Which one to buy or recommend or there is there a cheaper alternative just as good.
Thanks in advance.

I went to buy the original but when squeezed the squeak was really ear piercing, which helped me rule that one out! Would drive me potty!

I would recommend the rubber toy over the ring, my boy much preferred that, different parts and textures to bite depending on where the tooth was coming out.

My children loved the toy but not the ring one.

I wouldn't bother with the ring my DD loves the toy one and chews on the legs as well which is good for getting at the back to help with teething pains

Whichever one doesn’t squeak (which I think is the original in the white box). We were gifted one but it went straight in the bin as it’s so irritating. We also had a ring version that was a bit different to the one you’ve posted, DD loved to hold it but didn’t chew on it really! She was never that bothered by teething though.

Should I wait until my LB start show teething symptoms by use safe home objects first to observe what his preference
I think I would be irritated by the squeaker too. I was surprise that it sqeak everywhere on its body. Naturally went for the tummy to test then check other areas for texture but oh squeak squeak lol

Don’t buy a Sophie - they’re expensive for what they are and drool ends up inside through the squeaky bit and then they go mouldy

My kid had no interest in her Sophie. None. this is the only toy she’s never given the time of day to.

Buy the ring. The squeaky toy goes mouldy on inside with the drool.