Doesn't seem a very helpful or positive attitude MrsSlant by that particular teacher. I hope your DS does do the trial.
We have decided to get DS's English Language 'reviewed', as he is one mark from an A, so the risk of dropping to a B is unlikely. Isn't it funny how different teachers make such a difference to a pupils learning and experience? There's ones such as MrsSlants* as above, and there's DS's English teacher, who turned him from a B/C going in Y11 to 2 x A's, goes over and above every time and has enthused and motivated DS to reach his potential.
We emailed her yesterday, expecting a response when term restarts, and I had an email back within 2 hours, suggesting it was indeed a good idea to review.
If folk need to know, AQA charge £34.50 for a review.
We have been given the 'agenda' for the first few days back in sixth form, but no textbook suggestions.