Chesterfield schools: St Mary's or Brookfield

[Caitycat]

Any advice greatly appreciated, my dsis is moving back to this area and will need a school for dn, I've asked friends for advice and these two schools seem to have a good reputation but I'd appreciate some further opinions! Which is better?

My mum is from there originally and I have one of her sisters on fb, just checked and her granddaughter goes to Brookfield!!

She is away for Easter, not sure when she is back but I can send her a message for you!