My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Relationships

For all mothers of sons here are my handy cut out and keep tips on how to be a great mother in law, every one genuinely gleamed from YOUR threads!

170 replies

Slambang · 30/03/2009 20:30

To avoid the need for any more vitriolic MIL threads where poor misguided mothers of men are clearly going horribly wrong, I thought I would collate all your helpful rules for mother in laws into a single thread. Please feel free to add your own.

Note: These tips are based on my many years of arduous research reading Mumsnet.

Before the birth

  1. You may not tell dil that she looks tired or that her bump is growing. To dil this means you look like a big fat frump and not good enough for my darling ds.
  2. You may not tell dil she looks great. You are clearly not appreciating how tired and heavy she is feeling.
  3. You may NOT TOUCH DIL?s BUMP. EVER.


After the birth

  1. You may not expect to be invited to see the new baby on the day its born. Or the day after. Or the day after that. If you are lucky you may be allowed to pop in briefly (with presents) on about the 4th day when the REAL grandparents have gone.
  2. You may not comment that the baby looks like ds at that age. You are clearly not acknowledging that the baby is perfect, beautiful and just like dil.
  3. You may not bring as presents baby clothes (you clearly disapprove of dil?s baby style - how can she be expected to dress her pfb in that?), nappies (you disapprove of dils plans to use washables), bottles/ steriliser (HOW DARE YOU?).
  4. You may just be allowed to buy an expensive pram but only if this has not been bagsied as a present to be given by the real grandparents.


Growing grandchildren

  1. You may not help out at dil?s house. This is INTERFERING and implies she is not doing a good job.
  2. You may not visit dil?s house and expect to be fed a meal or any change in her pfb?s routine. She can?t just drop everything ? she has a baby, you know.

10. You may not pick up or otherwise hold pfb. This is disturbing and upsetting for all concerned and undermines dil?s parenting skills.
11. You may not buy extravagant gifts for pfb. This spoils pfb and undermines dil?s carefully planned regime of carrot sticks as rewards.
12. You may not buy cheapskate reduced items or pass on manky hand me downs to pfb. You clearly don?t value his/her unique wonderfulness enough.
13. You may not give pfb an affectionate nickname or otherwise abbreviate his/her (six syllabled pompous) given name. You do not have the right.
14. You may not expect to be visited on Mothers Day. You are no longer a REAL mother, you are now a mother in law. This does not count.
15. You may not chastise or in any way show any disapproval of pfb?s atrocious behaviour; whilst you may also not let pfb ?get away with murder? when you are kindly given permission to babysit.
16. Above all even if you forget all the other rules - the one golden rule. You may not pass comment or judgement, have any opinion or experience of any aspect of childcare. It will only end in tears.

please add your own.
OP posts:
Report
HarryB · 31/03/2009 15:11

Loving this thread.

Can I add the following:

MiL, you are pretty well off money wise so why do you buy my DS the cheapest shitiest 100% polyester clothes that give me electric shocks - and still expect me to put that near DS' skin. Are you crazy.

Report
IwoulddoDrWho · 31/03/2009 17:06

Ah that was a funny thraed for a while and then everyone started moaning about their MILs. I thought it was Americans who didn't get irony. I just don't get ironing.

Ps I heart my MIL.

Report
TheDOGmamma · 31/03/2009 17:07

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ruty · 31/03/2009 17:19

yep. the irony has been lost a touch...

Report
random · 31/03/2009 17:26

yep turned into another mil bashing thread ...was so funny at the start

Report
fraggletits · 31/03/2009 17:42

It's a really sad but true observation on a lot of women.....competitive and jealous over men, no matter if that man's your son, husband or brother.

I was viewed as the enemy by my MIL and SIL for a long time. I've always been much nicer to them (to their faces) than they've been to me, but I've let DH have it a few times about their behaviour once at home....which just makes him

Report
Justcallmereallystupid · 31/03/2009 18:52

I was like this with my mil once I had my dcs. After I split up with her ds she still made contact with me and dc. She was actually lovely but i couldn't see it at the time i was married to her ds. We started meeting up after my marriage ended. She died a couple of years ago. Im so glad we made peace before she died but god I miss her so much. I was such a c**t she was the best.

Report
ickletickle · 31/03/2009 19:44

what about "take your bloody annoying 20 year old camera with ridiculous flash away from the baby. there is a reason why she cries everytime you take a photo of her

and

"do not compare everything dil does to what daughter does. dil will never reach saintly heights of daughter, stop trying to make her.
"

Report
insertwittynicknameHERE · 31/03/2009 19:52

Apart from number 3 (cos I don't like anyone but DH touching my bump) I would love my MIL to do any of the others. It would not cause offense at all, but TBH I just don't think my MIL cares about DD.

Out of sight out of mind, even though I ring and text and email her regularly.

Report
seeker · 31/03/2009 19:54

Have the dils on here considered that their mils might think that they are a bit difficult? Or does it not work that way round?

Report
ItsGrimUpNorth · 31/03/2009 20:07

It would seem to me that unless DILs accommodate MILs every single wish, she will be regarded as 'difficult'.

As soon as a DIL says, "Hang on, I'm not happy about that,", oh dear, what a difficult woman you are, driving a wedge between a mother and her (grown) son and her grandchildren.

I think most people would like a quiet life. I think the problems arise when grown up children are not allowed to be grown up children to make their own decisions in life.

And IME, there are just as many men who find their MILs difficult.

Report
myermay · 31/03/2009 20:14

My goodness, i'd love my mother in law to do thoses things you've said "not to do".

I'd love her to offer to help with housework whilst i looked after my baby, i'd love her to hold baby whilst i got some sleep, i'd happily let her give our children all the love in the world and tell child off if it was being naughty. However i have accepted that i have a completely aloof MIL, who has "done her bit with kids" and now is happy to see the kids once a fortnight, even though she lives 5 mins away and then she doesn't play or interract too much with them.

All of you with a hands on MIL who adores your children whilst respecting you, LUCKY YOU!!! i envy you

Report
insertwittynicknameHERE · 31/03/2009 20:16

Maybe my MIL does consider me difficult, but when I tell her she can basically come here to see DD as and when she likes I don't think I am being difficult.

I also do not use grandparents as a childcare solution (I am lucky enough not to need to) but I have said to MIL that if she ever wants DD to herself to tell me when and I will do my best to make sure that DD has nothing on then.

My MIL just doesn't care but yes I suppose it is all me the nasty DIL for being difficult.

Report
myermay · 31/03/2009 20:16

My goodness, i'd love my mother in law to do thoses things you've said "not to do".

I'd love her to offer to help with housework whilst i looked after my baby, i'd love her to hold baby whilst i got some sleep, i'd happily let her give our children all the love in the world and tell child off if it was being naughty. However i have accepted that i have a completely aloof MIL, who has "done her bit with kids" and now is happy to see the kids once a fortnight, even though she lives 5 mins away and then she doesn't play or interract too much with them.

All of you with a hands on MIL who adores your children whilst respecting you, LUCKY YOU!!! i envy you

Report
random · 31/03/2009 20:19

If we back off we are not interested...if we offer help we are interfering ...damned if we do ...damned if we don't

Report
random · 31/03/2009 20:24

I'm a mil btw ..a lovely one tho

Report
ItsGrimUpNorth · 31/03/2009 20:32

As are DILs damned - ask for help with childcare, they've made their own bed and the MILs have done their share of child rearing.

Don't take up MILs on baby rearing advice, DILs are being rude and not including MILs.

Dare to breastfeed and you're excluding MILs.

That's why this is all so stupid with massive generalisations. It has to be case-by-case.

Report
insertwittynicknameHERE · 31/03/2009 20:51

itgrimupnorth, I soooo agree with you. DILs can also be damned if we do and damned if we don't.

When I was BF DD MIL had a big long ranty moan at me (DH was again out of earshot) that she couldn't feed DD. SO the next time she came I had made sure I expressed some milk. DD got hungry, I warmed the bottle up and asked MIL if she would like to feed DD this time. She said no because it was my job

Report
mrsjammi · 31/03/2009 22:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

mrsjammi · 31/03/2009 22:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

PrammyMammy · 31/03/2009 22:53

You know, i actually got along very well with my mil, untill i was pg with my ds. She once said,
"I thought you got pregnant in your stomach, not your face, you are looking like this puffs her cheeks out and makes funny face"
After that day, when i was clearly a bit miffed by the comment, she continued to make such remarks on me, then when ds came, i was wrong in every move i made, not just me but dp too.
Now i am pg again, and she hasn't even asked how things are, we had out 12 week scan 5 weeks back and she still hasn't wanted to see it.
BUT most of the things in the op wouldn't bother me, she showed up to see ds when he was minutes old, before i even went into a ward, and then went and stayed at my house untill i came home, and stayed the rest of the week.
We went through the whole bf episode where she thought i bf because i didn't want her to keep baby over night, he was 2 weeks old at this point.
Maybe i am a bad dil because i can't understand where she is coming from half the time, never mind put myself in her shoes.
GAH!

Report
WinkyWinkola · 31/03/2009 22:56

And you know what, I get tired of having to think of other people's feelings all the time.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

OldLadyKnowsNothing · 31/03/2009 23:41

As I said earlier on the thread, (back when it was still funny) I'm not yet a MIL, but DS2's GF is pregnant. I'll try very hard not to be interfering, but what do I do if the Other Granny - you know, the No1 one, the one the GF will still be living with - gives her the same advice she's given another of her daughters who recently gave birth? This was to put crushed rusk in the bottle of her three week old baby, because he's finishing bottles containing 4 fl oz and is still hungry. (

Report
seeker · 01/04/2009 07:04

" And you know what, I get tired of having to think of other people's feelings all the time."

Welcome to the hunam race!

Report
WinkyWinkola · 01/04/2009 07:57

Ah, I always knew my MIL wasn't really part of the human race!

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.