Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Should I challenge a date who hid having a girlfriend and lied about open relationship?

76 replies

ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:02

As title states, feeling like a total mug.
I met who seemed a fantastic, legit guy on a dating app and had one date where we chatted all evening, made out but no further intimacy. Lots of chemistry, but he seemed hesitant - I chalked this up to not rushing things, respect etc.

Fast forward to the following week, we met up and late into the evening did get very intimate. But alarm bells started ringing when I could hear his phone vibrating with missed calls, which led him to eventually take the call - but in a separate room far from earshot.

He could sense that I was curious and then asked me, "you know I'm trying out an open relationship with my girlfriend, right?"
It had been his gf on the phone and NO I did not know this - it was never mentioned anywhere. Not on his dating app, not in person. I had no proof.

I decided to not make a scene, but I instantly felt he was cheating and also upset that I had been lied to by ommission - especially after having just had sex. Before I had a chance to challenge him, he said his gf maybe wasn't feeling 100% comfortable with trying out an 'open relationship' anymore and maybe it would be best to leave things between us. I shrugged it off, assuming that was that, lesson learnt etc. Didn't actually know whether to believe him.

3 days later, he contacts me again with flirty messages... yes, I know I can block (although I have a fear of that, after a nasty experience with someone and a second phone), yes I can ignore him, no I wouldn't attempt to track down his gf - but I am just so angry he's assumed I bought this story about an open relationship and will probably gain the confidence to string along another person on a dating app again, for as long as he can, under the premise of 'open relationship'.

It's probably totally useless, but I can't decide whether to challenge him on this - not to pick a fight, but maybe just to rattle him a bit I.e. make it clear that women aren't buying the open relationship story and don't appreciate deception? Probably won't achieve anything...

Maybe best not to get involved further?
Ugh. Disappointing as he seemed so promising. I'm just a bit grumbly about it :(

(Caveats:

  • If they're genuinely trying an open relationship, then they're definitely not communicating or providing transparency that well!
  • I am not against open relationships or ethical non-monogamy, done properly and with transparency, but this smelt fishy... Couples typically state very clearly on apps if this if their thing and post photos of themselves together.)
OP posts:
MarthaLovesLaughing · 16/08/2026 15:05

Challenge him to what end? Nothing you say will stop him doing what he wants to do.

Jellycatspyjamas · 16/08/2026 15:10

Nope, nothing to be gained on challenging him. He knew exactly what he was doing and did it anyway. Shake the dust from your feet and move on.

ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:27

Yeah, kinda thought as much. Maybe I thought challenging him would save my dignity, because he assumed I'd lapped up the lie (I did feel quite violated). Maybe I'm just naive enough to assume duplicitous people will think better of it, so long as they're called out 🙃
And he had the audacity to do this in our local neighbourhood where we could all bump into each other easily ha
If he is indeed a cheat, he's not the most cunning of cheats

Hey ho

OP posts:
ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:27

Yeah, kinda thought as much. Maybe I thought challenging him would save my dignity, because he assumed I'd lapped up the lie (I did feel quite violated). Maybe I'm just naive enough to assume duplicitous people will think better of it, so long as they're called out 🙃
And he had the audacity to do this in our local neighbourhood where we could all bump into each other easily ha
If he is indeed a cheat, he's not the most cunning of cheats

Hey ho

OP posts:
Softcream · 16/08/2026 15:29

No I wouldn't challenge him, just leave it OP. What a loser.

MarthaLovesLaughing · 16/08/2026 15:30

No. Liars don't stop lying simply because someone catches them and points the finger.

Jellycatspyjamas · 16/08/2026 15:33

Your dignity comes from not engaging with his bullshit - don’t fight with a pig, the pig likes it and you just get mucky.

Mumlaplomb · 16/08/2026 15:36

Sorry this happened, clearly he was being deceptive. Just block him and move on.

Adventurewithadressinggownon · 16/08/2026 15:40

He’s totally mugged you off OP and your brain is trying to make sense or even justify it so you don’t feel hurt.

He doesn’t deserve a single ounce of your energy - block him

IslaLewis · 16/08/2026 15:50

Don't give him the satisfaction of knowing you're thinking about him.

Who knows what he was up to?

Maybe he's even married!

The best antidote is to off load to friends all you like but not pursue him for an apology or 'hands up, I'm guilty and you're right'.

ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:52

Dammit :( well, I wonder how long he'd have strung it along if his girlfriend hadn't panicked him with missed calls...
Maybe an emotional bullet dodged.
Stinks for his gf and any other women he tries it with, nonetheless.
Block it is!

OP posts:
ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:57

Also forgot to mention that he seemed a bit of a sexual fantasist. Even as he was hurrying to put his shoes on to leave, he was telling extravagant tales about random threesomes he'd had with his gf and her best friend
He had rather lost his credibility by then 😂

OP posts:
Hatty65 · 16/08/2026 16:01

I'd send one message saying, 'Yeah. You and your girlfriend might be interested in an 'open relationship'. I'm not, however. Bye'.

And then I'd block.

IslaLewis · 16/08/2026 16:05

Hatty65 · 16/08/2026 16:01

I'd send one message saying, 'Yeah. You and your girlfriend might be interested in an 'open relationship'. I'm not, however. Bye'.

And then I'd block.

Not worth the effort. Silence speaks volumes.

IslaLewis · 16/08/2026 16:05

ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:57

Also forgot to mention that he seemed a bit of a sexual fantasist. Even as he was hurrying to put his shoes on to leave, he was telling extravagant tales about random threesomes he'd had with his gf and her best friend
He had rather lost his credibility by then 😂

what a loser

outerspacepotato · 16/08/2026 16:06

Don't waste your time.

Not blocking leads him to think you're actually into him. You would be best off blocking him.

IslaLewis · 16/08/2026 16:06

ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 15:52

Dammit :( well, I wonder how long he'd have strung it along if his girlfriend hadn't panicked him with missed calls...
Maybe an emotional bullet dodged.
Stinks for his gf and any other women he tries it with, nonetheless.
Block it is!

How do you know it wasn't his wife and she needed him to help get the kids to bed?

TFImBackIn · 16/08/2026 16:07

IslaLewis · 16/08/2026 16:05

Not worth the effort. Silence speaks volumes.

I agree - I'd just block, even though I'd be writing messages in my head for a while.

bitontheobtuse · 16/08/2026 16:09

Don't challenge him. Dump him. Job done.

Herenowatbroad · 16/08/2026 16:09

Why bother?

I wouldn’t have even wasted time starting this thread about him

Herenowatbroad · 16/08/2026 16:10

I reckon that he had second thoughts about having sex with you

Pineapplewaves · 16/08/2026 16:18

Block, move on, don’t give him another second of your time.

He’s got a girlfriend and he’s looking for someone else on the side. He doesn’t want to give the girlfriend up.

IslaLewis · 16/08/2026 16:24

There is no proof it was a girlfriend.

He could be living with a woman and told her he was on a lads' night out or at work- who knows- and she wanted to know when he was coming home.

ByRoseSnake · 16/08/2026 16:26

Herenowatbroad · 16/08/2026 16:10

I reckon that he had second thoughts about having sex with you

I mean, it's possible, but it seems like a very elaborate story to concoct haha. Usually people just ghost if they're not into it (also not cool)
Plus the frantic missed calls, plus his gushing over threesomes, plus his follow up flirts several days later once the dust had cleared
I'm inclined to believe he's just been cheating
Will move on from it :)

OP posts:
ginasevern · 16/08/2026 16:26

I expect it was his wife wanting to know what time he'd be home to help with the kids. In fact I've no doubt she'd be quite surprised to find out she's apparently in an "open relationship". It basically translates as him snatching a shag on the side whenever he can. He sounds vile, but he's far from alone in his sex class.

Swipe left for the next trending thread