Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Regretting our choice of godparents after family fallout over my daughter

90 replies

OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 05:27

I am feeling really down and looking for some opinions and guidance.
My husband and I chose his brother and his brothers wife as the godparents for our child. We are Christians. It is a decision I took very seriously as my faith is important to me and I want my daughter to have a fulfilled life and godparents who want to see and love her. They had been supportive during the pregnancy and early newborn days. However things took a turn when my baby was diagnosed with a disability and I was admitted to hospital for postpartum depression. My sister in law started saying I caused it by having a c section (i had an emergency, traumatic birth) and not breastfeeding her. She has made alot of upsetting comments. I eventually sent a message explaining how I felt. It was approximately one week after they had their new third baby (in and out of hospital one hour , very easy birth and feeding). I was very calm in the message and only described in terms of my feelings, not talking negatively about her. I requested she not keep bringing up my birth and feeding failures.
Anyway my sister in law didnt take my message kindly and has been recently excluding me from family events. She did not even invite me to her baby's baptism, let alone make me godmother. She told my husband they wanted him as godfather but would not have me. He declined as he though it would hurt me too much. It has indeed hurt me deeply. I feel so much guilt to my daughter for making them her godparents, as it seems lile they will no longer be in our life

OP posts:
OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 10:17

user1492809438 · 13/06/2026 10:07

Your sister in law does not sound very Christian.

She isnt
Only on paper
But I was blinded by her fake generosity and kindness in the beginning....

OP posts:
OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 10:20

waterrat · 13/06/2026 08:18

I think many people.pick godparents and then the relationships change . I am no longer close to any of the people.i picked snd i feel.a.bit sad when I think about it.

What matters here is trying to.get on with your actual family and letting stuff go so that you can get on

Try not to think about the godparents issue

Thanks
Its just raw and painful at the moment

OP posts:
Anon501178 · 13/06/2026 10:46

OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 06:30

How have things been since then? What do you do for things like Christmas?

It's not always been easy....we are also NC with DH's parents for similar issues, so we don't attend 'family' events anymore.
We do see DH's other siblings still and usually see them over xmas.
We got excluded from a family wedding and everyone else was invited which was hurtful (DH's parents had lied to the groom- DH's nephew- saying we said some things we didn't, and unfortunately he has not spoken to us since)

Biggles27 · 13/06/2026 11:56

My daughter’s now grown up but 2 out of her 3 Godparents are no longer in her life (one is a family member)

she is mega close to her remaining Godmother who has more than made up for the other two and we’ve promoted her wife to Godmother. No she didn’t stand in Church and make a sacred vow but her actions speak much louder

she has shown up for my daughter her whole life and has treated her as one of her own - the two Godparents haven’t even sent birthday cards for her 18/21 birthdays. They didn’t come to her engagement party and we won’t bother with the wedding

she now has fierce women in her life that love her beyond measure, this is worth more to me than the sorry excuses I chose nearly 25 years ago

SisterMidnight77 · 13/06/2026 11:57

I wonder if the message you sent her was as ‘neutral’ as you are making out.

SweetnsourNZ · 13/06/2026 12:13

OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 05:40

Thank you. It really is awful. I believe you can choose different sponsors at confirmation time. But this all seems so far in the future. It is hard to get through the now. Last night I was up all night regretting trying to set a boundary for what it has done to the family.

Time will fly by. I believe a lot of churches do 1st communion and confirmation at the same time not long after they start school. My son did this 30 years ago.
There is nothing stopping you making your new choice now and the new godparents taking over now as it doesn't seem like the old ones are going to be aware anyway.

SweetnsourNZ · 13/06/2026 12:17

Enko · 13/06/2026 06:03

This is a fairly common subject so lets not troll hunt without proof. Report the poster if you have suspicions.

@OpenFinch I would agree that mediation may be a good idea. As would counselling for yourself to find some peace in this. Perhaps making a will and expressing your wishes for your dd would support you to get peace surrounding this

Edited

I remember a post similar to this but do not remember the posters child having a disability and I think their baby was still newborn. Could be wrong though.

SweetnsourNZ · 13/06/2026 12:20

Jellyofftheplate · 13/06/2026 06:25

People ask about the birth but it doesn't mean they are judging the answer.

I also couldn't have been arsed with someone sending a load of self indulgent nonsense just after I'd given birth. You timed that really badly.

I agree. As much as the sil sounds like a pain in the butt sending a message like that to a hormonal new mother was never going to end well.

Harry12345 · 13/06/2026 13:29

TheWardrobeIsThere · 13/06/2026 08:54

A couple of things, we were raised Catholic and it seems that no one I know has an aunt or uncle as a godparent. The belief being that your family will be part of your life anyway and provide good role models (alcoholic domestic abuser in my case) so you choose close friends.

Secondly, if your faith is important to you and you want to stay connected as a family talk to your priest about all of this. After all the Christian message is to forgive.

I was raised catholic and it’s all aunts and uncles who have this role, it’s more a special bond

BuckChuckets · 13/06/2026 14:15

OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 05:48

No? This is my first post. I am confused

This is 100% the poster who is very, very mentally unwell and needs proper support, not to repeatedly post on MN.

Dogmum74 · 13/06/2026 14:32

OpenFinch · 13/06/2026 05:27

I am feeling really down and looking for some opinions and guidance.
My husband and I chose his brother and his brothers wife as the godparents for our child. We are Christians. It is a decision I took very seriously as my faith is important to me and I want my daughter to have a fulfilled life and godparents who want to see and love her. They had been supportive during the pregnancy and early newborn days. However things took a turn when my baby was diagnosed with a disability and I was admitted to hospital for postpartum depression. My sister in law started saying I caused it by having a c section (i had an emergency, traumatic birth) and not breastfeeding her. She has made alot of upsetting comments. I eventually sent a message explaining how I felt. It was approximately one week after they had their new third baby (in and out of hospital one hour , very easy birth and feeding). I was very calm in the message and only described in terms of my feelings, not talking negatively about her. I requested she not keep bringing up my birth and feeding failures.
Anyway my sister in law didnt take my message kindly and has been recently excluding me from family events. She did not even invite me to her baby's baptism, let alone make me godmother. She told my husband they wanted him as godfather but would not have me. He declined as he though it would hurt me too much. It has indeed hurt me deeply. I feel so much guilt to my daughter for making them her godparents, as it seems lile they will no longer be in our life

Yup. Yet another example of how god fearing Christians are arseholes

JoyousWriter · 13/06/2026 15:26

Statistically, your child is unlikely to be a Christian as an adult so I wouldn't worry too much.

When you update your will, your choice of potential guardian is the only important thing.

itsnotalwaysthateasy · 13/06/2026 23:10

I have no idea who my godparents are. Im 54 and not one of them has shown themselves in all these years.

OpenFinch · Yesterday 02:03

BuckChuckets · 13/06/2026 14:15

This is 100% the poster who is very, very mentally unwell and needs proper support, not to repeatedly post on MN.

I do not know who you are referring to. I've been searching the forums for this person who apparently has a similar story to me. It is unfortunate because I came here with pretty bland common issues hoping for some guidance, as they are really weighing me down and some posters keep just comparing me to some other random!

OP posts:
OpenFinch · Yesterday 02:04

Anon501178 · 13/06/2026 10:46

It's not always been easy....we are also NC with DH's parents for similar issues, so we don't attend 'family' events anymore.
We do see DH's other siblings still and usually see them over xmas.
We got excluded from a family wedding and everyone else was invited which was hurtful (DH's parents had lied to the groom- DH's nephew- saying we said some things we didn't, and unfortunately he has not spoken to us since)

That is terrible. Some people play really dirty

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page