Look, I can see how people think that women make bad choices. I understand that instinct. BUT... why do they make those choices? Because they don't do it in a vacuum, I assure you. They do it because society tells them it's THEIR fault if their men are bad. That their expectations are too high. That they should do things differently etc etc etc.
DH and I knew that exBIL was a feckless, useless, waste of space. And we tried to tell SIL that before they had children. But she didn't listen. not because she was desperate for children, but because everyone else was telling her that she was the problem.. MIL constantly complained that SIL had ended previous relationships with "nice" men and was "never satisfied". FIL listened to exBIL's stories about how volatile SIL could be and man-to-man agreed that SIL was "difficult" and she was lucky he stuck around.
exBIL went around telling everyone what a caring person he was, and how kind and how difficult his childhood had been and that is why he behaved badly sometimes ("I wear my heart on my sleeve" was his catch all phrase for when he had, yet again, been rude, unpleasant and surly to anyone and everyone. "I just can't control my emotions because I never learnt how as a child") and all the people who didn't actually know him told her how lucky she was to have such a "nice" guy and assured her that if she just supported him, he'd get over his trauma and be better....
DH and I were screaming into the void because we were the only ones who saw him for the lazy, manipulative, controlling ass that he was. I, in particular, was vilified for being so mean and for trying to break them up (DH, of course, can do no wrong in the eyes of PIL).
And the frightening thing is that his behaviour wasn't even particularly hidden compared to a LOT of the "bad" men you hear about or read about on here. we all saw his moods and the way he would sulk (it irritated PIL but they thought it was just a bit childish and that SIL should have been nicer to him in the first place to avoid the sulking). They saw how little he contributed but apparently, that didn't matter because he was "devoted" to SIL and at least he'd never cheat or leave her, and really, she should just ask him for help at home and if she just helped him more and supported him more, perhaps he'd gain the confidence to work more or find a new job. It was ALL on her. ALL of the time.
So yes, part of me is so tired of the fact that she still hs the noose of her ex around her neck because he's such a useless waste of space and she should have known better. And part of me is deeply sympathetic because I listened to all these people telling her that SHE was the problem for over 10 years.