Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

I had a relationship with a married man

98 replies

SpringEquinox84 · 10/07/2022 16:16

I know this thread will attract a lot of negative comments and maybe I need that but mostly I need advice on what to do or how to move past this.
Apologies for the length, I’ve tried to explain it all.

I met a man about 3 years ago through mutual friends, we instantly got on like a house on fire. He’s married (7 years, no kids) but it didn’t mean anything as we were solely friends, we became really close and he started to confide in my about his problems at home. He would tell me how unhappy he was, how he got married too young, rushed into it and now him and his wife are different people and their life is just not a marriage. He said his life is not what he wanted it to be, he would talk about how he really wanted children and she didn’t and how his life feels so empty. He told me it’s rare they would have sex, maybe a couple of times a year on the typical ‘special occasions’ and they would often argue and sleep in separate rooms.. whenever they would talk about it, they would say they would try to make things better.. but it would always go back to how it was.

Trying to be a friend, I gave him advice on what may help improve things or if he wanted to walk away that would be fine too, a lot of marriages end. It’s still just a friendship for us at this point.

fast forward another six months and we start to spend more time together and I realise I’ve developed feelings for him. I tried to ignore this but it becomes apparent he also has feelings for me.
we both knew it was wrong but couldn’t stay away from each other and we began seeing each other romantically and in all honesty, it was amazing. I’ve never felt happiness like I had when we would be together, we would spend as much time as possible together and I fell in love with him, completely. It wasn’t just sex, we would have days out at the beach, meals at restaurant, long walks together etc. I knew he was still unhappy in his marriage but we didn’t really talk about it, almost as if we ignored it it wouldn’t be there.
we would talk about our future together and I saw such a change in him, from the miserable, depressive man I met 3 years ago, to this really happy, positive loving man.

we would spend time together and he would get visibly upset that he would have to leave and return to his ‘normal life’. He would tell me over and over again that he wanted to be with me and only me, that he saw his future with me.

A year in I decided I needed him to actually commit to me and told him this. He said he will find a way to end his marriage. He didn’t want to tell her he’d fallen in love with someone else as he didn’t want to hurt her even more than ending the marriage would.
weeks went by and no change. I told him we can’t go on like this and he said that he wants to be with me more than anything, but can’t leave her, he feels so guilty and he would rather he suffers in a life that makes him unhappy, than put her through the pain of a divorce.

I genuinely believe he is unhappy in his marriage but I just can’t understand why he won’t leave if he does. I understand that he doesn’t want to hurt her, but he’s hurting both of them by carrying on with such an unhappy life.
I obviously told him that if he can’t commit to solely me then I have to walk away, it can’t keep going on like this.

I just want to hear peoples opinions? Have I been an idiot? Has anyone had anything like this?
Do I do anything? Tell the wife?
what do I do about him? Just cut him out my life? Try and be friends? See if he ends his marriage? Please help :(

OP posts:
Macbeth8 · 10/07/2022 16:18

He isnt unhappy then 🙄 he has fed you the script.
Have you ever seen him and his wife together? Imagine you are a fly on the wall, you will never know how they are behind closed doors. You've only got his word on it.

Blossomandbee · 10/07/2022 16:21

He wants his cake and eat it. He's playing you both. He's telling you the same old chestnut they all say. He doesn't love you and he could leave his wife if he wanted to....he doesn't want to.
In the nicest way, you need to get some self respect and move on.

lonelydad2022 · 10/07/2022 16:22

You cannot be serious.

Macbeth8 · 10/07/2022 16:23

You want advice on what to do? Leave him in his "unhappy" marriage then. Let him "suffer" as he says. Maybe he will come running to you soon enough after living through the torture. ((Smirk))

DontBlameMe79 · 10/07/2022 16:24

For him, it is just the sex I’m afraid. All the other stuff he says is fluff.

I suggest you make it the same - and if you can’t, end it.

vodkaredbullgirl · 10/07/2022 16:25

That old chestnut, he will not leave her.

Mumoblue · 10/07/2022 16:25

If this is real it’s literally cheating scumbag 101.

Yes, I’m afraid you’ve been an idiot. If he wanted to leave his wife he would.

litterbird · 10/07/2022 16:26

Sigh….you’ve been played. If he was that unhappy he would have left a long time ago. He won’t leave now. Dust yourself off, learn from this mistake and move on. Remember, HE WONT LEAVE HIS WIFE!!

ArcticSkewer · 10/07/2022 16:27

Men are generally a bit useless.

This type 'fall into' things - marriage, vaginas ...
Stuff happens to them rather than them making it happen.

If he really wanted to leave, he would be so awful that his wife would leave him.

harri2214 · 10/07/2022 16:27

i agree, u have no idea how things really are and if he is really unhappy but refuses to leave, then it leaves you no choice other than to move on and forget about him. It sounds painful and i'm sorry for you and also his wife but i would get out of this situation if i were you. "You said "he feels so guilty and he would rather he suffers in a life that makes him unhappy" but he is also making u suffer so i he obv doesn't care about u that much if he's happy to string u along while staying with his wife in their marital home. Sorry if it sounds harsh but this is one of the risks of getting involved with a married person (no judgement).

forrestgreen · 10/07/2022 16:30

My exh told his new girl we were unhappy and had drifted apart. I told him that would have been great to hear from him at the time. He had no plan to leave me, was just enjoying all the fun of the fair.
He made promises to me, she didn't but she still has no morals!

EVHead · 10/07/2022 16:33

He’s a cunt, you’ve been an idiot - end this farce now.

AMindNeedsBooks · 10/07/2022 16:34

Sorry but agree with PP. If he was that unhappy he would leave.

Why would he think his wife would be happy living with someone who is miserable and cheating on her? Don't you think that would be more hurtful than breaking up? If it's that bad of a marriage she'll want out too, surely? If he had kids that would be his excuse not to leave, he's just found another one.

You need to cut him off completely. You won't 'just be friends'. There is always the chance he might leave her once he knows you're serious but I really doubt it. He definitely won't leave her if he knows he can have both.

It really is the same script every time. This is why people should not entertain married people.

melissasummerfield · 10/07/2022 16:36

Oh come on OP you know this makes no sense!

He has told they are unhappy, don't have sex, argue and sleep separately so why on earth would his wife be heartbroken if he left?

Tell him to leave you alone, he is never going to leave what his wife probably thinks is a happy marriage!

AMindNeedsBooks · 10/07/2022 16:36

When he was acting miserable, was is it when he was talking to you about her or when you've seen him with his wife?

ArtistViv · 10/07/2022 16:39

Maybe he's telling the truth, maybe he isn't. I think in this instance, you need to look at what you DO know, instead of focusing on what you don't. You do know he's married, and you do know he's said he can't leave his wife. Please believe him.

It will be very hard to remain friends with him - you'll always be hoping for more and things will most likely segway back to you being 'the other woman', once again.

I've never been in this situation myself, but a friend has. It went on and on and on for many years. He never left his wife, and my friend gave up most of her 30's and early 40's to this guy (she desperately wanted kids and never ended up having them due to wasting so much time on the married guy). If you remain in his life, what are you giving up? Because it sounds like there's already been a price to pay for you in terms of personal happiness... there always is in these instances. Is it worth it?

Sorry if this sounds trite... but life only moves in one direction for all of us. Imagine you're 80 years old, thus knowing you're possibly nearing the end of time here. What would the advice to yourself be with regards to this?

Happiness is sometimes making a really hard decision when it means we're going to be heartbroken for a while.

AuntieStella · 10/07/2022 16:41

You need to cut him decisively out of your life.

The fantasy version might have been great, but the reality is that he's a shit

I think his wife ought to know, but it is not for you to tell her. Because you'd be doing it from the place of a pile of emotions damaged by that horrible man, rather than from support and concern for her well-being (remember that everything he's told you about her will have been an outright lie or twisted to suit his selfish agenda).

Yellowflowers4 · 10/07/2022 16:43

I mean this nicely. I just got out a relationship in april where I thought I knew the guy. I thought we were closer than anything and we both had a mutual closeness.

Turned out he was abusive. He wasn't fully commiting. He was a liar. He was performing to an extent. He was probably only with me because his ex wouldn't have him back. She agreed to a friendship but he spent the whole relationship bringing her into our relationship and making me feel crap..he wouldn't even put us on Facebook in a relationship. The real reason why? He did not want to commit to me. He wanted me to think he was. So he could get what he wanted. Which in my case was mostly money and a mug to look after him and do forms and buy his food.

I know you have had lots of beautiful times together. But you deserve 100% and his poor wife deserves 100% honesty and the choice to move on and get away from him. If he stays with her now hes lying. He's either too afraid to loose his cooked meals. Laundry washer. House tidier. Financial security and comfort.

I don't believe you can be truly in love with more than one person. If he can cheat on her and have sex with you and spoil you with the time she should be spoiled. Then why would she want him..

Imagine how that poor womans going to feel for years to come imagining you two together.

I don't like liars. He's a liar. Do you really want a man in your life capable of this and still not thinking your worth all of him. Tell him his wife likely won't want him now anyway. She probably wants an sti check and some therapy instead for the occasional time he has sex with her.

Aquamarine1029 · 10/07/2022 16:45

He saw you coming a mile away. It's fucking incredible that you actually believe all that bullshit he fed you.

Shgytfgtf111 · 10/07/2022 16:47

Don't tell the wife, that would be purely selfish in the hope of forcing his hand. It won't.

inmyslippers · 10/07/2022 16:48

Well I would say he's full of shit. You believe he's unhappy but take it for what Is definite. He's not leaving his wife.

boopdeflouff · 10/07/2022 16:51

Come on.... give your head a shake.

Pugfostermum · 10/07/2022 16:53

He’s not that unhappy and if you walk away he will find someone else on the side.

His wife likely has an awareness, but tolerated it/maybe does the same herself.

I don’t think you can be friends after this.

Ravenclawdropout · 10/07/2022 16:53

So when you first met he had been married 7 years and now he has been married for 10 years?

You know this man is a liar and a cheat and willing to string you on indefinitely. If you think a couple who have only been married 7 years and who don't have young kids, aren't having sex you are naive to the extreme.

Don't tell his wife and ghost this man 100%. He is a toxic player and you are gullible. Getting involved in their relationship will just drag out the pain and make this drama play out longer. It will also be very difficult to hear from his wife that they had an active sex life all this time and he won't try for a baby and she didn't know why (or similar). This man's whole life is a lie. You had your illicit passion which made everything so exciting: HE IS NEVER GOING TO LEAVE HER.

Find a man who is available and isn't a cheat or a liar.

Feart · 10/07/2022 16:56

You won’t get a balanced view on here OP do don’t take any of the comments to heart. Nobody on here knows if he’s telling the truth or not. The only way you’ll find this out is by giving him an ultimatum. If he’s serious then he will leave, despite what you are told on here plenty do actually leave. It’s far more complicated than the MN ‘Well if he’s unhappy then he’ll leave’ There are so many things to consider, divorce isn’t pleasant and not seeing your kids full time isn’t either. It took me 5 years to come to the decision to end my marriage.