Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Sister doesn't want me to be her bridesmaid. Sad.

81 replies

hockeypuck · 04/10/2007 12:12

I got married ten years ago and even though my sister and I weren't close she said "I'm going to be your bridesmaid you know" so I accomodated her, got her the dress she wanted even though it was different to the other bridesmaids because she was too big for the monsoon dress they had.

She's getting married next year and it's a totally grand affair, huge country house, costs about 6 times what our wedding did, plus she's 14 years older than I was when I got married, so it's just different to my wedding and that's fine.

I made a point of not asking to be bridesmaid. As I wouldn't want her to be obliged. She has asked my DD to be her flower girl but no comment was made about me.

She has asked me to do a lot of the planning, organising etc and said she'd talk to me about bridesmaids later. She phoned today and said "oh x, x, and x are my bridesmaids, we'll have to think of a role for you, do you want a name or title or are you have happy looking after your dc's"

"the bridesmaids are going to wear nice dresses from Karen Millen or Coast or somewhere but they don't do your size so you can't be one" (I should add here that she is big too, so that shouldn't matter)

"I love my bridesmaids to bits but there just there to look pretty and party but I want you to do all the organising and sorting things out"

I feel really hurt by this. I haven't told her that because I don't want to ruin her day. I certainly dont want to be a bridesmaid if she will regret me being one.

But I feel really unwanted. I am sitting here crying my eyes out, something I haven't done in a long while, but I just feel unattractive ugly and hurt.

How should I deal with this?

Give me a kick up the backside and tell me to grow up if you think that's what I need!

OP posts:
Boycodd · 04/10/2007 13:46

yes i get htat but i reckon she can so get he point wihtout you needing to be obvious.

imo the vets way to piss her off an show her is to lose weight and then if she asks you to be one say" oh no sorry i haev already got a dress"

if she is porky thtall relaly hack her off

so tomorrow is hte day!

Songbird · 04/10/2007 13:49

Absolutely, make her sorry!

hatwoman · 04/10/2007 13:51

the vets way to piss her off? are vets reknowned for being good at pissing off their sisters?

duke748 · 07/10/2007 10:09

I agree that it seems that there is a lot of miscommunication going on here.

But also some competition?

'She's getting married next year and it's a totally grand affair, huge country house, costs about 6 times what our wedding did, plus she's 14 years older than I was when I got married, so it's just different to my wedding and that's fine.'

Does it really matter what it cost or where it is? Or how it compares to you? Isn't a wedding meant to be an expression of your love for somebody not outdoing those you love?

Maybe this whole situation is just a continuation of some unresolved sibling rivalry? And that is why you are being mean to each other (intentionally or not)?

Maybe if you both worked on that you could have a better relationship and that could mean no more miscommunications.

Alternatively maybe she remembers your wedding differently. Being made to wear a different hideous dress while the other slim bridesmaids had fab dresses and being made to feel that her size was a problem as you told her all about the difficult search for a dress that would fit her. Now she is getting you back?

You need to speak to her but not to demand a suitable role, but to let her know that her comments hurt and try to resolve things.

Good luck!!!!

hockeypuck · 07/10/2007 12:04

I can see where you are coming from Duke, but I dont think there is rivalry between us in relation to that. I think she's simply self-centred and wants things how she wants them. She works in a very demanding management job where she bosses people around all day and is very good at it. I think she has thought of planning the perfect wedding as organising people at work and is therefore treating me like an employee.

I sent her an email saying "i think I must have understood what you were saying, I'm feeling a little hurt but hope I have the wrong end of the stick and we can sort something out".

I got a one line reply...

"i just wanted to know what job you wanted to do"

that's all, no sorry, your upset, I do want you involved or anything.

OP posts:
edam · 07/10/2007 12:05

Being a bridesmaid sucks. Be glad you are out of it!

Fireflyfairy2 · 07/10/2007 12:15

Snap!

My sister got married last July & she asked my dd to be her flowergirl. I am her closest sister & the others are 10 years older than her so I thought she would ask me to be her matron of honour...

We went shopping for dresses, I was the one who actually picked her wedding dress.. and we both held up the exact same bridesmaids dress at the same time..

When we came home from the shops she text me to say she had asked our niece & her fiance's sister to be her bridesmaids...

God I howled into my pillow... not because I wanted to be the centre of attention, but because I had been good enough to go & do all the donkey work with her, she went & picked her flowers, booked the hotel etc... all with me!!

Perhaps this was her way of involving me in her wedding without my rolls of flab runing her wedding pics. I'm a size 14 (was about a 16 then though) and the others were size 8/10. In the run up to the wedding she even complained to me that our niece had gained weight....

Sorry, no advice, just wanted to say that I know exactly how you feel.

MrsCarrot · 07/10/2007 12:30

Sounds like she's being extremely selfish to me. I don't get this 'concessions for the bride being rude as she's stressed' business, or why you can't say how you feel as it's her day.

She's basicly asking you to do all the work of the cheif bridesmaid without any of the perks. Personally I would hate to be an adult bridesmaid but if she's ignoring you gently telling her she's hurt your feelings then I would be in forming her that she needs to find a someone she considers atractive enough for the dresses who is also capable of fulfilling the duties, and that you will be attending in a beautiful dress of your choice and getting drunk.

MrsCarrot · 07/10/2007 12:34

"Perhaps this was her way of involving me in her wedding without my rolls of flab runing her wedding pics. I'm a size 14 (was about a 16 then though) and the others were size 8/10. In the run up to the wedding she even complained to me that our niece had gained weight...."

Firefly That is outrageous

hockeypuck · 07/10/2007 14:50

firefly and for you.

Can I just ask, how did you deal with the day itself? Having to be there for your daughter but not be involved in that way yourself?

OP posts:
princessmelBABY · 07/10/2007 14:53

I'd tell her how unhappy you are. And how rude she was. Especially as she is asking/expecting you to help her out.
What a cheek.
If she makes the comment about you not fitting in the dress then I'd remind her of the bridesmaids dress she wore to your wedding.

You need to tell her so its not just left and then you'll stew over it.

I'd be very upset too.

octavia · 07/10/2007 14:55

I've just looked the pictures of your beautiful children on your profile hockeypuck,she is obviously jealous as they must take after you (don't write back and tell me they look like their dad cos I wont belive you).If she wants you to run around after her either tell her where to go or call yourself a "wedding Planner" and charge her for it.

ADragonIs4LifeNotJustHalloween · 07/10/2007 14:55

"but I want you to do all the organising and sorting things out" !!??

I'd tell her to f&&& off TBH.

princessmelBABY · 07/10/2007 14:56

firefly I can't believe people can be so unkind.

dweezle · 07/10/2007 17:33

HP - I've just had a quick nosey at your profile and my goodness, what a woman! 2 beautiful DCs - they are gorgeous, you are obviously sparklingly intelligent, with lots of interests and talents, well read. No wonder your sister wants you to do the organising! Maybe she thinks you will show her up, being obviously so much better at life than she is..................

Fireflyfairy2 · 07/10/2007 22:46

Hey hockypuck.

That day I got my dd ready at home & had to call in to drop her off @ my sister's house. She asked me to put her veil on & we had a hug... I actually cried as we were/are v.close.

I wept in the chapel too & then when they were outside getting pics taken. I had a 2yr old so it was easy enough to keep busy that day!!

fullmooncupsugar · 07/10/2007 22:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MeMySonAndI · 07/10/2007 23:14

Just another reason of why I hate weddings.

She may be bridezille but really, she deserves a rainy wedding day!!!

hockeypuck · 08/10/2007 09:56

MeMySonandI - great name by the way - yes she does deserve a rainy wedding day, but I hope it's not rainy cos it'll mess with my hair too!

Dweezle and Octavia - I'm going to print out your comments and keep them with me. You have made me feel so much better about myself, thank you so much. It's easy to let one comment drag everything down, but I wont let it now. I shall remember the rest!

You are lovely ladies - thank you for making me happier again!

OP posts:
CappuScreamO · 08/10/2007 10:03

I wouldn't do any of it

I would tell her I was too damn busy

or I would turn up in an overall and a hairnet when she asked you to do anything

also I would tell her she looked really fat in her dress

I would say things like "I think ivory will be better because white is really going to make your face look red"

Kewcumber · 08/10/2007 10:04

Hockey - don't have anything constructive to add as I was (reluctantly!) a bridesmaid for my sister. But if you look any like your DD, you are most defintiely NOT ugly! She's very very pretty.

She's just being an arse. Buy yourself somehting fab and go have a wild time yourself without any organising crap.

CappuScreamO · 08/10/2007 10:08

kewcumber is right

she is being an arse

ScaryScaryNight · 08/10/2007 10:17

Many years ago, and this is not related to a wedding at all, when my oldest was just 6 months old, and I still had a lot of baby weight, my sister came to visit (13 years older than me). I was getting ready to go out, we were going to spend the day in Kew Gardens, and she looked at me and said:
"Cant you find something else to wear, I wouldnt be able to make any photos of you when you look so fat. God, you look like some clay figure my daughter made in school".

I did not talk to her, I sent her out of my home, she flew home without having spoken to me. I did not speak to her for ONE YEAR.

You seem to be a more reasonable woman than I am.

But please step aside from the organising or you will feel like a doormat.

snowleopard · 08/10/2007 10:22

Well you could say "OK since you ask, I had hoped I would be a bridesmaid, as you were one at my wedding."

However I agree it's probably better to rise above it and be glad you're not having the hassle of being a bridesmaid, and will be free to choose what you wear and enjoy yourself with your DCs and make a fuss of them in their roles. That will take your mind off it (and yes they are gorgeous!)

I went to a lovely wedding this year where I had helped my friend with a lot of the organising, but did not have a "role". I didn't mind - I was running around after my DS outside during the ceremony, and was freee to play with him and chat to friends etc. I know she's being really insensitive but I think you will have a better time if you let it go. And I agree she may be jealous of you in some way.

snowleopard · 08/10/2007 10:27

Wow SSNight - zero tolerance!

I think more people should react that way to rude family members - not stand for it. But in this case I wouldn't because it's a wedding and not fair to the DCs who have been asked to take part.

Swipe left for the next trending thread