Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Husband blaming everything on me

83 replies

5fha · 01/07/2020 16:41

Hi all, I've found myself in quite a mess and posting on here in the hope of reading some advice and/or moral support. I'm confused and very hurts.

I'm in a 15 year relationship (married for five) and it's been pretty good overall. I've loved being in a relationship, and he makes me happy the majority of the time.

Back in January my husband, who's usually incredibly close to his family, suddenly decided they annoyed him and that they were too demanding of his time (they all live about an hour away and ask to see us a couple of times a month, so not excessive). He also decided he was depressed at work and had no enthusiasm for his job anymore. I asked if he was depressed, he said no. I asked if he was happy in the marriage, he said yes, very happy. Anyway, this went on for months, with his family getting increasingly upset by him not wanting to visit or even talk to them once lockdown started. I felt stuck in the middle as I also wasn't entirely sure what was going on due to my SO's lack of communication.

This goes on until earlier this month when his brother decides to do an intervention and randomly pitch up at the house demanding answers as to why the family are being shunned. So they both sit in the back garden to talk while I sit upstairs, thinking this would be a good way to give them privacy and allow them to talk it out. A couple of hours later, his brother leaves and my SO comes into the house all smiles. He says it's all sorted and he feels massive relief. Awesome! I think. All that weirdness is now over.

Except it's not, as he then tells me that we need to sit down and talk. He then commences to tell me that he's been unhappy for 'ages' and the reason is me. I ask him what is it I've done exactly that's made depressed but all he says is "it's just the way you are". All this despite the fact he'd spent the last few months telling me I'm the best thing in his life, his rock, the only person he wants to see. He'd even said he wishes everyone else would leave alone so he could spend forever with just me! It made no sense. I asked what we do now, do we split up? But he said he doesn't want to as he respects his vows. I just need to change a few things about myself - what these few things are he couldn't say, and I'm still to this day none the wiser. I spent ages crying, but he got irritated with me saying that I should be happy for him as he now has all the family stuff sorted.

This was a couple of weeks back and he's all happy and being extra gushy with his family. He's also gone back saying I'm amazing and he's lucky to have me. I'm utterly fed up and feeling worse as time goes on. The way I see it, he was genuinely pissed off with his family for whatever reason but decided it's easier to throw me under the bus than be honest with them. But he sticks to the story that it was all caused by me stressing him out. And now refuses to talk about it at all.

Is this worth splitting over? I thought we were happy and very much in love. I know the obvious thing to do is to discuss it over, but as mentioned, he won't and it's eating me up and makes me feel worthless. Part of me says to go on as normal and hope this never happens again. The other says if he can do this then he doesn't truly love me. Sigh...

OP posts:
1235kbm · 01/07/2020 16:45

I'm not surprised you're confused. Sounds very strange.

He seems to have made you the scapegoat OP. I wonder if he told his family that you're responsible for their estrangement?

Did he give no indication at all of what you're meant to have done?

Jengnr · 01/07/2020 16:50

He is fucking with your head. Anytime you displease him now this will come back up until you are tied up in knots. I’m sorry love, it’s over.

Theworldisfullofgs · 01/07/2020 16:50

I'd say for the marriage to survive you need to seek help.
He manages things through avoidance and then blame. Seeking help would be my condition for not leaving. You can't remain like this, its eating away at you.

ComeOnBabyPopMyBubble · 01/07/2020 16:54

There could be a few options and neither of them are good tbh.

  1. He made you the scapegoat to his family and laid the groundwork for any backlash. You'd be imbalanced if they started questioning you , things not going well would confirm his story etc.
  1. If there was a real issue his brother managed to make it all about you and how you're the "real" reason your DH feels that way.
  1. Your DH is at least emotionally if not mentally as well , unstable and he's swinging from one extreme to the other depending what benefits him.

4.His family knows something you don't (affair,gambling,addiction etc) and gave him an ultimatum to sort it out or they'll tell you. Again blaming you was laying the groundwork for either leaving OR if you found out to justify his behaviour.

An honest, cards on table, no you can't walk away from this is needed. If he still doesn't have the answers you seek And the reassurance you need, then the relationship is pretty much fucked.

5fha · 01/07/2020 16:54

Yep, according to him he told his brother everything - that he was quiet due to him being utterly depressed by me. He also apparently said that they shouldn't hate me as I've not depressed him on purpose.

When it comes to whatever it is I've apparently done, all he said was that it's just who I am, that our relationship is toxic. When pressed for more info he just clams up. I've even tried the whole "how can I change if you don't tell me how" route but all I get is "I don't know, it's just you".

Which is all odd as now I'm apparently back to being the perfect wife.

OP posts:
CarlaH · 01/07/2020 16:57

He sounds mentally ill.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/07/2020 16:58

Whatever the fuck is going on in his head - well, he tried blaming the family. They've obviously convinced him it's not their fault. So now he has dumped it on you instead.

I'd insist he takes himself off for some sort of therapy.

In the meantime, please withdraw from him a bit. Don't allow him to dump this on you. You know it isn't you. It is him. He just doesn't want to admit that to himself. He needs someone to blame.

5fha · 01/07/2020 16:58

Thanks so much for the replies - loads of food for thought. I am starting towards the thought of sitting down and doing The Talk. I just want to know why he did what he did, what's the actual truth and if he storms off to his parents (which he's done in the past, but not for years) then I suppose that's my answer.

OP posts:
theproblemwitheyes · 01/07/2020 17:00

OP, i think your husband is unwell. All of this behaviour sounds incredibly bizarre and worrying. Mood swings and personality changes can be symptomatic of lots of different medical conditions, if i were you I'd do everything i could to get him to see a GP.

5fha · 01/07/2020 17:06

Going to the GP sounds scary but a good idea. It'd be a battle to get him to agree (he point blank refuses couples counselling), but I could definitely try.

OP posts:
Nicolastuffedone · 01/07/2020 17:07

Could you perhaps ask his brother what your husband said to him? This is very odd.....

TheFlis12345 · 01/07/2020 17:20

My first thought, like a pp suggested, is that his family know something you don’t so he wanted to avoid them. His brother has now promised they won’t tell you so he will see them again.

Aquamarine1029 · 01/07/2020 17:28

Suddenly "unhappy for ages", you are the problem, you need to change but he won't say how or why... Sounds like the beginnings of The Script to me.

Anydreamwilldo12 · 01/07/2020 17:29

I would be contacting the brother and ask what was said in the garden between them.
Your husband is messing with your head and his attitude is seriously weird. You do not deserve to be treat this way and need answers. He can't just say it's you who's causing his 'depression'' and then not tell you what exactly you have done to make him feel that way then be all bloody lovey dovey with you. I would be furious!

5fha · 01/07/2020 17:37

With regards to his family, they are very much one of those "family before absolutely everything" types and my husband has mentioned in the past that he finds them a bit suffocating with their need to be in each others' pockets, but has never gone off on one like he did earlier this year. They're also very protective of him as he's the youngest. I honestly do think he was generally fed up with them but didn't have the guts to say so.

I've thought about contacting either his sister or mum (the brother has gone rather cold on me), but feel that it'll be seen as me making excuses so as not to paint a bad picture of myself. He can do no wrong in their eyes.

OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/07/2020 17:45

the brother has gone rather cold on me

Presumably he believes whatever bollocks your husband has told him.

needhandhold · 01/07/2020 17:50

This all sounds very weird. It’s not good because all trust has now been lost. Is there any chance of an affair? Could you move out? Give him an ultimatum. Move out and then message him saying you’ve left. You will only be back after a full explanation as to what’s happened and what’s been said. If not you’ll file for divorce, force a sale of the house and he won’t see you again. You’re not putting up with this rubbish. You’ve been a good wife and you deserve better but if you have to you’ll get rid permanently and find somebody trustworthy. I’m sorry but I think you need to go hardcore and hold your nerve. This is no good. You’re best getting answers now while you’re young enough to start again or you’ll be here again in a years time when he decides to do this again.

needhandhold · 01/07/2020 17:52

Read your update. He’s told the brother that he stopped talking because he’s depressed and thinking of ending the marriage. I bet they are now giving him sympathy/attention. He is a coward and a liar and he’s thrown you away to avoid owning up to his own decisions. Really really shitty.

VettiyaIruken · 01/07/2020 17:54

Sounds like when his brother came round he simply didn't have the balls to actually tell him how he felt so he came up with a load of bollocks.

Mum45678 · 01/07/2020 17:57

Agree with @Aquamarine1029 - Sounds like the script. I'm so sorry OP.

Tlollj · 01/07/2020 17:59

They know something you don’t know.
He kept you from them in case they told you.
Brother came down and your dh told him some bollocks or another, blamed you, now it’s all your fault.
I’d phone his mum his sister his brother find out what’s gone on. Something stinks.

1235kbm · 01/07/2020 18:02

Why would he cut off his family if he's having an affair?

Eckhart · 01/07/2020 18:03

This sounds awful, OP. He's done such a dramatic about turn, twice, that there's no way you can trust what he says anymore.

He might need to see a doctor, as PP's have suggested, but that won't make you trust him again. I think it's over. I'm sorry. I think you're better off out of it. It''s not a good relationship if he's flip-flopping so wildly with your emotions, and the fundamentals of your relationship.

It's not you, though. Hold onto that. Even if you'd done something drastically wrong, his behaviour would still be an unforgivably hurtful way of dealing with it. The fact that he can't even specify what you've done, and that it's 'just the way you are', is potentially very emotionally damaging for you. It's NOT you.

needhandhold · 01/07/2020 18:05

Is he having an affair?

Bluntness100 · 01/07/2020 18:10

Christ if my husband told his Family he was depressed by me and telling me our relationship was toxic I’d be out, how embarrassing with his family, they will all be giving you the side eye and how horrible for your marriage.

On a seperate note he sounds like a self absorbed arsehole.

Swipe left for the next trending thread