Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Engaged and dreadfully unhappy

81 replies

rogerfed · 15/11/2018 15:47

I've posted here before about trust issues with my fiance but he has always managed to talk me round. It seems he is a Jedi master at persuasion. We're about to buy a beautiful house together and get married next year. Everyone loves him and I mean EVERYONE - my kids, my family, my friends. He is very jovial and kind hearted, but in many ways is incredibly selfish:

  • he makes decisions unilaterally, often informing me of them after the fact
  • he has lied to me repeatedly, some of the lies have been small and insignificant, some have been whoppers.
  • we don't really have a lot in common and our conversation is often superficial, whereas I love nothing more than a good deep conversation
  • he works incredibly hard and that seeps massively into our home life. That won't ever change.
  • he has had problems in the past with putting appropriate boundaries in place with other women. He is flirtatious and his inappropriately close friendship with another woman almost ended a marriage.
  • he is very 'blokeish' and can often act like a teenager when other people ask about our relationship - like it's embarrassing
On the flip side he can be incredibly generous and thoughtful, but it seems like every week (and sometimes multiple times a week) i get hurt feelings about something he has said or done.

But because so many other people love him and are cheering for us, I'm honestly concerned that I am sabotaging a good relationship. This would be my second marriage, but I've had lots of previous healthy relationships - I think I know what they look and feel like. Surely the fact that I am so unhappy and anxious says something?

Has anyone else broken off an engagement and really regretted it?

OP posts:
33goingon64 · 15/11/2018 18:22

If you feel like this now, how are you going to feel in 2, 7, 15 years time? Marriage is supposed to be forever. If he's pissing you off now it won't be a happy marriage once the confetti has been swept away.

Somethingwentwrong · 15/11/2018 18:23

Can you see a relationship counsellor on your own to talk things through and help you reach a decision?

WitchyMcWitchface · 15/11/2018 18:30

People appear to love him and appear to want you to get married because they wNt you to be happy and you appear to have found you dream man. If you made any suggestion that you weren't happy about the relTionship they would take a different stance.

rogerfed · 15/11/2018 18:30

I have had the beginnings of the difficult conversation with him, which went horribly as I knew it would. I feel strangely numb, but the fact that I'm not heartbroken probably speaks volumes. Thank you all for the benefit of your experience, your wise and funny advice, the unmumsnetty hugs and flowers - I will need them over the next wee while as I untangle everything,

OP posts:
DarklyDreamingDexter · 15/11/2018 18:30

Surely the fact that I am so unhappy and anxious says something?
No, it says EVERYTHING!

Renarde1975 · 15/11/2018 18:31

New research has shown that the gut is actually our "second brain" and is responsible for instinctive feelings and the subconscious so if it's screaming at you listen or you will get ulcers, sleepless nights, a permanent niggling feeling of something not being quite right and no peace of mind.

Loving what Prettyvase is saying.

Rottie454 · 15/11/2018 18:36

I broke off an engagement and it was the best decision I've ever made. Money had already been spent on the wedding, we had bought a house together, had a dog and a cat together and I kept using these as excuses as to not leave but I am SO much happier now cause of it and now I know I am with the right man Smile

Hellsbells35 · 15/11/2018 18:39

It should be easy. Marriage should be like hanging out with your best friend everyday who you also want to sleep with. Trust is a huge part of that. You can’t be with someone who hurts you weekly?! It’s alwaus easier to untangle your lives than it seems and I expect when it’s over you will hear people’s real opinions which may well match your own!

category12 · 15/11/2018 18:49

Good luck OP - calling it off is absolutely the right call. Being unhappy and anxious in the relationship is what you need to know about it.

littlebillie · 15/11/2018 19:04

Trust your instinct

AFistfulofDolores1 · 15/11/2018 19:16

I think one of the most courageous, and life-affirming, choices we can make is to follow our own sense of what is right when everyone and everything else is telling us we are wrong.

Flowers
Bluesmartiesarebest · 15/11/2018 19:55

He lies to you
He upsets you
He makes decisions without you
He is inappropriate by overstepping boundaries
He is immature
He is a workaholic
He is superficial

I would end the relationship for any of those reasons.

SandyY2K · 15/11/2018 20:28

You're doing the right thing OP.

lifebegins50 · 15/11/2018 21:27

I had so many doubts over my Ex but failed to trust myself...it will be my biggest regret in my life and I am living with the consequences as it has cost me my health and finances.

Like the earlier poster I blamed myself for lack of commitment, as he was obviously a "good catch" and he had less obvious flaws than yours! My instinct was strongly warning me.
Whatever he is like now...it could be worse after marriage.

babbi · 15/11/2018 21:27

Good luck OP .... trust your gut xx
Wishing you all the best in your happy single life ... you sound so lovely

TheWiseWomansFear · 15/11/2018 22:32

If you don't love him... don't marry him!

PolkaDoting · 15/11/2018 22:51

You can’t be married to someone who lies to you!

GladysKnight · 15/11/2018 23:48

the lies would be enough really. You don't need to say anything else, to him, to friends and family,, or to yourself. Total dealbreaker.

Orlandointhewilderness · 16/11/2018 00:05

I didn't break off the engagement. I got married. The morning of my wedding I kicked everyone out of my home and watched Moulin Rouge and drank a bottle of wine, crying. I felt enormous pressure to marry him - everyone had worked so so hard for my wedding and I couldn't bring myself to admit that I just didn't want to spend my life with him. I had loved him madly, but I was only 20 and I knew it was completely superficial and more like playing at life. I'd started to grow up by the wedding but didn't have the courage to stop everything. It ended, of course, ten months later when he slept with the fiance of a very close friend of his and it took me years to recover from.
I have a wonderful life now, and a wonderful love in it but I will never forget lying on my floor on the morning of my wedding crying. It is far easier to call it off now.

rogerfed · 16/11/2018 00:18

Thanks to everyone for continuing to post. It’s definitely the lies that have been the ultimate dealbreaker. There’s just no fixing that!

OP posts:
pallisers · 16/11/2018 00:48

Let other people marry him if they love him so much.

The lies and the unilateral decisions would be enough for me but the other stuff doesn't sound great either - plus it sounds like he just isn't really your type.

OP, you really should only marry someone if you sincerely love them, trust them and know you can live with their faults. You don't sound remotely near this. Break up, tell people he was nice but you weren't compatible enough for marriage.

My experience in life has been that once a woman leaves one of those men everyone loves, people start saying what they really felt about him.

Charliecatpaws · 16/11/2018 01:02

My ex was and is still a liar, I can’t believe a word that comes out of his mouth, our kids (20 & 16) both realise that he’s a liar just by their own observations, however he has a ,mr nice guy, persona that most people see you only realise when you get to know him properly

RainbowsArePretty · 16/11/2018 02:41

What you describe is not a good man or a good relationship. End it now, before marriage & the house purchase complicate jet all

Ooplesandbanoonoos · 16/11/2018 02:51

People might not love him as much as you think maybe they are just being polite about him to you.

LellyMcKelly · 16/11/2018 04:18

You are unhappy with him. That is LITERALLY the only reason you need to leave a relationship. Do not marry him if you are not happy.