Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Why do men crawl out of the woodwork years later?

78 replies

Chuckle17 · 08/05/2017 16:50

I had a very brief but intense relationship with a much younger man ten years ago. It ended horribly when he dropped me like a stone and then proceeded to blow hot and cold on me for a few months until completely ignoring me.

He popped back up a while later to apologise for his behaviour and that was that.

It's now ten years later, I am married with children and he, as far as I'm aware, is single. He has now messaged me to ask how I am, whether I think about what could have been etc. It's taken me completely by surprise and I'm completely bewildered. I would still love an explanation as to why he behaved the way he did, and whether any of his feelings were genuine. But i know I will never get one. And I certainly would never want to rekindle anything.

But it has got me wondering why men do this? Are they genuinely remorseful and full of regret, or do they really just get their kicks this way?

This is not the first time I've had an ex pop up. Always after a bad breakup, but never after this long.

OP posts:
mimishimmi · 09/05/2017 03:43

Tell him you never wonder how things could have been because you've found someone much better 😄

mummytime · 09/05/2017 05:49

Some people have a weird kind of ego, and really don't want any of their exs to have really got away. So will occasionally tug on the line to check you are still hooked, they might not even be interested in sex etc. But I does their ego good just to know you are still there.
I'd suspect someone has just knocked him back so he's just checking to rebuild his ego.

Beansonapost · 09/05/2017 05:57

Ex contacted me 3 months after I had my daughter...

I had not seen or spoken to him since we broke up... 5 years later a message in my Facebook inbox.

He knows I'm married and have a child (children now) as we still have a few mutual friends... I showed my DH and we had a laugh as the message was so pathetic, it wasn't even congrats or anything. He just wanted to know "when we were going to catch up" Hmm. I would have liked that pleasure when he cheated and then dumped me after 3yrs.

Also he had been removed from all social media, but I suppose facebook still allow people to send messages. thank god I no longer use fb.

It's always sex!

Chuckle17 · 09/05/2017 06:40

I'm shocked, but also somewhat comforted, by just how common this scenario is.
I ended up telling my DH last night as I felt on edge in case he tried to contact me again. I found myself putting my phone out of sight just in case and that's not right.

OP posts:
user1479302027 · 09/05/2017 07:43

I think they also like to shit on another man's territory, as they would see it. It works, too, because they get in the mental space of their exes and chosen partner. It's pretty immature!

ShatnersWig · 09/05/2017 08:06

Just for balance, I'm a man and I've had an ex-girlfriend do this as well. Twice, in fact.

CheersMedea · 09/05/2017 15:31

Him showing up ten years later has thrown me. I can't believe someone would be that sadistic?

This as others have said is for sex plus ego boost but the 10 year thing... a number of things going on.

First - no reflection on you - it is likely that you are at the bottom of the pile. If he's hit a dry patch, men like this have a "little black book" of potential future shags, current shags, most recently ditched, mid-term ditched and historic. They tend to work through on almost a rota system. The longer ago it was, the more likely you are at the very bottom of the pile of the desperate. As I said - nothing to do with you personally - it's just how they work.

Second - if he has any understanding that he hurt or upset you, guys like this will figure "if I leave it long enough she'll forget, just remember my marvelousness and be desperate to have me back" it's not even a conscious thought. It's the same way the ghosters figure "if I don't formally dump her, there is always an entrée back".

Third - if he was aware he hurt you, chances are in his little egotisical world, he has no real conception of how hurt because he is emotionless - it's all about his ego.

Guys like this really get off on seeing the flare of hope in the Ex's eyes that this time will be a fairy tale ending. But all the time, he's just in a dry patch and sharking around for other newer fish to fry.

Chuckle17 · 09/05/2017 19:47

I looked at his Facebook page and yes it looks like he may recently have broken up with the latest in a line of short lived girflfriends!

OP posts:
AlphabetSoup3 · 09/05/2017 21:57

I have to admit I did this, contacted a school crush when newly single!

TinDogTavern · 09/05/2017 22:23

Happened to me too. An ex from a not especially serious or enduring distance relationship. Called me after FIFTEEN YEARS. Which will teach me for never changing my mobile number. Definitely looking for a shag. Ironically I had now moved much nearer to him AND was single (and a bit desperate) but I STILL didn't pursue it because I thought it was a bit creepy and grim.

HarmlessChap · 09/05/2017 22:42

Just for balance, I'm a man and I've had an ex-girlfriend do this as well. Twice, in fact.

Yep happened to me too a couple of times, I found it odd.

I don't necessarily think its sex I think people often contemplate on the crossroads events in their lives and wonder what might have been if the paths were different, probably if they aren't happy with how it's all turned out.

Never contacted any of my ex's though, it wouldn't even occur to me to do so.

LesisMiserable · 09/05/2017 22:52

I've had it done and I've also done it myself. Not for sex, maybe for ego, familiarity, nostalgia.

annandale · 09/05/2017 22:52

Oh that's interesting Shatner and harmless. Like you it never would have occurred to me to do this.

Actually, that's not true at all. I sometimes have daydreams about winning the lottery and immediately instructing a dodgy private detective to find out everything about what my xh and his family are up to. I guess the need to pursue unfinished business can strike anyone. I also suppose it's more honest to do it face to face!

FreeNiki · 09/05/2017 22:52

Whatever it is it isnt because they miss or want you.

They want an ego stroke

user1493759849 · 09/05/2017 23:11

Have to agree with a PP. It's not just men who do this. Although I have had it happen twice in the distant past! Men just messaging to 'catch up.' I ignored them btw.

I know a few men who have had an ex contact them to say hi and ask to meet up, when they KNOW the man is taken/spoken for/married. It's fucking twisted. I have no idea why they do it; it really pisses me off. It's like 'I know you are married/have kids/in a relationship etc etc, but I am so hot and sexy and utterly irresistible that I know you will cheat on your current partner for me.

Cunts.

PoorYorick · 09/05/2017 23:16

We know it's not only men, but the overwhelming majority of users here are straight women.

Howlongtilldinner · 09/05/2017 23:24

I'd love my ex to contact me (8 years on now) there's a few questions I'd like him to answerHmm

TheStoic · 10/05/2017 07:02

Wish you'd respond just as you did here. Grin

He claims to have thought about me a lot over the years and what could have been, and asks if I do too.

Truth is I do. But not in the way you mean. I had a huge attraction to you physically and we got on well. But you were immature and not going anywhere fast. If we had ended up together I'd not have had the nice life I've had. I gather you are still living with your parents and doing not much with your life.

lollirossi · 10/05/2017 08:45

I have had this happen to me on several occasions please allow me to get a few off my chest!

My first serious boyfriend who I dated from 15 to 17 dumped me because he had met a "better prospect" at uni and wanted to be free to persue her. I was hurt of course but fair enough. When his better prospect failed to pan out he thought he'd just go back to me but luckily I'd moved quickly as you do at that age. In the next few years anytime I met him or he sought me out he'd want to get together and catch up, when I refused he'd resort to telling me that I used to be nice but had turned into a real bitch ... nice! Luckily I haven't seen him for a decade now.

Boy I was friends with at uni and liked was never interested in me because I wasn't hot enough fair enough, a few years after uni he writes to me out of the blue announcing that he is in love with me, always has been Hmm. When I write back to tell him thanks but no thanks as I'm already taken I get hit with a barrage of insults (in my experiance insults are par for the course when you reject a man for what ever reason).

Another guy I went out with at uni and who I'll admit I was crazy about wouldn't commit to me in anyway because quite frankly I wasn't Bjork and he felt he was destined to be with her. He still sniffs around every once in a while boohooing about his "mistake" totally disregarding the fact that I am married and have been for well over 10 years.

Ditto for another toxic boyfriend I had before I met my husband, he was your typical sexy bad boy back in the day but is a totaly gross middle aged pothead now and yet still thinks I secretly long for him, deluded.

With some exceptions, I agree that it is all about ego for these men and nothing to do with us at all. In most cases they are looking for an ego boost, sex or a fallback position and some of us might even have given into them in the past because we loved them but I don't think thats a healthy position to be in.

After all my dealing with arseholes it was such a revelation to me to be with a man (my now husband) who wasn't looking over my shoulder for the next best thing for whom I was the prize and thats the way it be.

Interestingly every single man I've listed here is still single and they will all be between 40 and 43, I must have had duff taste back then!

I would say that yes in the past at low ebbs or when single I have thought about past boyfriends and crushes and wondered where and how they are. The difference is that I never went as far as contacting any of them because while felt tempted to see them I realised that they had moved on and most likely had zero interest in seeing me again.

For these men who do think getting back in touch is a good idea must have very poor emotional intelligence. It is like they think that because they are thinking about you, you must be thinking of or hankering after them, or that they are so amazing you would happily drop your husband / family to be with them. Its just so infantile and creepy and if they ever did get you back don't expect them to trreat you with any respect you'd just be another one on the line.

With that said I am sure there are notable exceptions to these men but I'd think they are quite rare.

rosabug · 10/05/2017 08:48

I read something once that about sums it up. Men can be like dogs - They keep returning to sniff their own vomit.

Crude, I know - but It's true. To be fair women can be like this as well.

Chuckle17 · 10/05/2017 10:06

Love that analogy!

Howlongtildinner - You won't get an answer. I have tried with this particular guy in the past. He can't explain his behaviour past saying that he "was a cunt".

OP posts:
FindingJessica · 10/05/2017 20:18

Is it generally younger men who do this?

SuperPug · 10/05/2017 20:26

Gah...
Attention and control.
Can I still get attention from a variety of women? Nice little ego boost for him.
Do I still have an element of control over her/him? A bit of a power trip .
There's a reason why people like this are still single...

reetgood · 10/05/2017 21:37

It's not younger men, in my experience. I think they just don't see the harm in asking, and enjoy the fantasy of who you were/ who they were.

I've had it from two exes who were content to let me go ( or they chose something else). Fortunately not from the absolute arse of an ex

heartbroken40 · 10/05/2017 21:55

Well, I fell for it. He came back after 23 years and yes, I still thought about it all the time.

after texting for one year, we had sex and then he dumped me for a younger girl.

Why wasn't this thread written one year ago? It would have saved me so much heartache.

I am so disappointed with myself. I am so stupid!