Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Very Private Significant Other

82 replies

georgiatraher · 01/03/2016 13:46

My boyfriend is very very private, to the extent that it is starting to bother me.

He is very careful about PDA and never gives me more than a peck on the lips in public. He does introduce me as his gf to other people, but is not affectionate in public. In private it's different, he's more affectionate and loving, but I wish he'd show it in front of others. The worst part is if I go to kiss him or touch him he will pull away from me, which everyone else reads as rejection of me (although I know he doesnt feel that way).

He is generally private about his feelings as well. He tends to tell his close female friends more than me, or that's what it feels like. His mother recently went into hospital and he didnt tell me about it for a while. I know there's nothing I can do about that situation but he's pushing me away emotionally when I try to help by cooking him dinner or doing all the chores for him. "there's nothing you can do." is a hurtful phrase he's used. It all stems from his overly private side of him.

If I try to approach these subjects he makes out like I am trying to change him.

OP posts:
StarChaser99 · 01/03/2016 23:04

I don't necessarily agree with the posters that have suggested that this is somehow malicious/calculated on his part, but I do agree that you're just not compatible.

You need more affection in public than he is prepared to give. Neither of you is wrong in this it's just fact. And whilst its strange that he is comfortable being affectionate with friends and not you, I think in his mind the two things (friendship and relationship) are completely different and therefore he responds differently. He may have a self consciousness in public about his relationship that he just doesn't have with friendship.

I also think you need more emotional availability than he can give. Due to various differences in our background, my DH can be much more emotionally closed than I am. But I get him and he gets me and therefore it's not a problem for us. In your case it's not clicking, again neither of you is wrong in this, it's just that your expectations are different and they don't match.

I think that the fact that he didn't call to tell you that his mum was in the hospital (even if he didn't want to talk about how he felt about it) is evidence that there is some disconnect between you.

I don't think this is anyone's fault, I think you are maybe just not right for each other.

lougle · 01/03/2016 23:17

I've been married nearly 14 years. I don't feel the need to put my hand on my husband's shoulder or stroke his arm to 'join a conversation'. Why do you feel the need to point out that you are in a relationship?

Stillunexpected · 01/03/2016 23:24

Why do you have to touch him in order to join in a conversation at parties? I would shrug my DH off if he did that! Presumably if you walk up to friends at a gathering you don't feel the need to stroke their arms in order to make your presence known?

TendonQueen · 01/03/2016 23:29

He's not interested in the things that are important to you and doesn't pretend to be, but it's convenient to him to continue the relationship in private at least. Don't settle for that. Tell him you've realised it won't work as you're too different and it's time to end things. It will drag on painfully otherwise. Make a new start.

SmillasSenseOfSnow · 01/03/2016 23:44

At parties he should be the one guarding you so other men don't think you are available!

That's what pda us about. Standing close to you. Holding your hand. Arm round you. Watch others at parties. A lot of men don't realise they are doing it. But it's a protective instinct guarding what's theirs if you like. Animals do it too. With proximity.

I would not (and do not) tolerate any hint of this from a partner. Eugh.

Headofthehive55 · 02/03/2016 20:26

purple dasies
It's more a reflection of animal behaviour - we are after all animals and there are responses that happen that you don't consciously do. Standing close to someone , open stance and mirroring their actions is a sign that one likes the other. Friendships, relationships, you see it in both. Nothing to do with 1950s just millions of years of evolution. Desmond Morris wrote at length on the subject in particular his book manwatching is excellent.

Headofthehive55 · 02/03/2016 20:31

I wouldn't want my DH constantly holding my hand at a party I agree, I'm just trying to it explain from a behaviourists point of view.

We do things so unconsciously, watch how many girls stroke their hair when talking to someone they like! Hidden body language can be quite revealing.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread