No I don't think she would change, she has never shown any type of indication that there could be something wrong with her, or any desire to develop.
I remember her coming home (when I still lived there) from a routine GP appointment fuming that she'd been offered counselling. 'That's for MAD people' she spat out in anger 'how DARE he do that to ME' etc etc etc...
It was only when I got a lot older that I realised that she probably was/ is very unwell, and probably upset/ scared about it hence the denial and over reaction.
She would call me mad, mentally defective, disgusting and unstable... For daring to swap a-levels and other shocking crimes of madness and lunacy. Sigh.
I'm not sure how personal or not it all is/was. I'm still working that out. Until the last few years it felt very personal. After all, she had a family of 3, and I was the only hated one. I was the one she made into her scapegoat and whipping boy. She definitely singled me out, and her personal attacks would have left mumsnet banning her all over the place (!).
No matter what happened, I'd be to blame. One of the constants in family life. And I thought I was inherently bad for many, many years.
I have come a way from that point though it's hard to shift the belief of a lifetime. I can see how cruelty can be very precisely & intensely aimed at one person, and still not be personal as such. In that, it could have been anyone standing here, being me, that would have got it in the neck.
A few years ago, I had a really good counsellor, only 12 sessions when DS had just been born and I was getting poorly, but remember them as a really pivotal moment.
Anyway, he really put his finger on it by looking at the whole family dynamics vs individual relationships.
It never did quite sit right/ feel the straightforwarda story of 'mother= abuser, me = victim. Though this last year, I'm finding that simple story more and more convincing!
Anyway, when opened up to broader family dynamics it struck a chord with me.
His idea was that I was never meant to be an actual person. Therefore how could it be personal. My whole personness was rejected so whatever and whoever I was, I would have always failed and be hated.
I was born to serve a purpose within the family, to serve a function. So every time I stepped outside of being a role, by, you know, being an actual person, I would be punished for my human-ness. So basically, I was born to fail.
Made a lot of sense at the time though sounds a little bonkers now!
Everything revolved around my sister (which it did, even before she got sick). So it was always about my mothers relationship with my sister (golden child - except no jealousy here as she was actually very lovely not to mention she absorbed a lot of my mothers focus so took the heat off me)
Then my mothers relationship with my dad (& wow was that dysfunctional!).
Then me.
The family story is that they had me as a HV said that my sister needed socialisation.
Apparently it's not normal to have this in your family lore? Not sure about that but it made sense for me to be born to be a prop for my sister, and everything about me was defined against her and makes sense of the weirdiness.
I existed to 'bring her out of herself' to give her a friend, someone to play with, and of course a protector at school, someone to be more confident, less shy etc.
And why I had to have short and bloody awful ugly hair (as my sister had long beautiful hair), why I wasn't allowed to wear white or pink, or even anything very girly (as my sister was the dainty girly one, I had to be the tomboy), why I wasn't allowed to be good at X as it was my sisters special thing (my mother actually asked the x school to hold me back 3 years in a row so I didn't overtake my sister when she first got sick)... Etc etc etc.
Almost screwed up my alevels completely as I was only allowed to do Maths & Sciences as the arts belonged to my sister. When younger I was told off for getting (very) good marks in English, and sworn to silence/ sent to room. It took years for me to understand that the ht was joking when he 'told me off' for dropping 2% on my 11+ English. I mean literally I dropped 2%, got 100% maths & 98% English and I only remember that as I was so upset at 'having failed' which is what I thought had happened due to the reaction at home plus the teachers ill advised comment.
Same for every bit of my life, all strictly controlled and me always in the wrong. And woah, when I revolted at 17 and refused to sacrifice my future on the altar of 'don't be nasty to your sister' weirdness - & I refused to carry on towards my super low predicted grades & no uni acceptances.
That's when the awful screaming arguments appeared, with lots of threats of 'taking me to a psychiatrist' to either 'sort me out' or 'lock me away' (very Victorian), and much talk of refusing to let me leave home and making do a job on a local farm instead (err, yes indeed id be an asset to any farm ooh ahhh I would .
I joke now, I was fucking terrified.
But I got out. Thank fuck.
Anyway, without even going into the whole weird jealously stuff I think it makes sense, and why no matter what I did, I was always hated and vilified.
And the freakish twisted reversa Oedipal type awfulness from my mother who hated the perfectly normal father-daughter relationship, and did everything she could to destroy it (worked too for a very long time, and then again at the end I guess it worked for her again).
And so I know I'm up posting about it all late at night again, but by trying to put the pieces together, it helps.
It's hard to remember that its aimed at me but I could be or do anything and it would still be the same. It's hard to keep two things in my head at once...
Overwhelmed by the breath-takingly awful things she did to me last year. And then oh yeah, it wasn't aimed at me, except it was, in a way... And not in a way. Bleugh. Brain ache.