Good morning, afternoon, evening all: it may take all day to post and all day for it to be read. I was ready to severely edit, but decided not to...big scab. Is this the longest post? I have gone on and on like Miss Bates in Emma!
I will admit that I (dh,too) have a personal policy of not looking for problems, which has helped our marriage endure, no doubt. So in digging into this...I feel like I'm jumping into a dark hole and just hope I'll be able to get out again without finding myself dripping in hatred for Middle Sister.
But Middle Sister's behavior is so unacceptable that I need to build my wall for me as well as for my family. It is time. No reservation, no qualification, no more 'go with the flow' (ie: her flow ).
Thank you for the prompt, Ally. Your question "Was Middle Sister ever corrected?" was right on target-the perfect question. I feel I ought to fill in with more back ground about childhood- sorry it turned out to be a long freight train full. I am still working on the answer (it's dark in this hole ).
My parents treated us (3 daughters) equally, and we all believe it. Now I have the urge to question that.
Older Sis was adopted. Parents never brought it up past telling us (or did we find out from mean cousins?) and we never threw it up into her face as children (maybe once or twice 'joked' about it as adults but in kind hearted way). Mean cousins would though, very hurtful. After rejection by social clique (mercy! small town politics!-part of the overall web of circumstances), Older Sis turned into a rock and roll hippy flower child of the '70's which griped my conservative parents no end. She rode horses (Dad bought one when she was 13) and she taught me how to ride when I was 10. Boys were around alot, and she did get into trouble with drugs and law (no jail). She was the one to stay out all night once or twice, partied through the first semester of college 24/7 (Dad put a stop to that-no more college) and she finally ran away the following spring to return a few months later pg. Parents got her a termination (I've never spoken to her about it but she has expressed remorse at never having children). BUT she straightened out, got married and became a nurse, and she is well respected as a pro-active patient advocate for the elderly. She works in a nursing home, not an easy job.
Middle Sister is two years younger, a goody two shoes, church and school choirs. She probably did/does have middle child issues (I'll try to look into that angle of it). She developed a weight problem in adolescence that has continued to the present. She was not athletic before her weight problem and definitely not afterward. She got on a horse once, it ran away with her, she would not ride again (may have ridden once on a vacation, but generally does not ride). Even though she was a part of a social group from choir, she never had a boyfriend. She liked -perhaps was in love with- one of the neighborhood guys, but he laughed at her because of her weight. I don't think she ever got over it because she still has never had a boyfriend. She socializes, in college and presently, in groups including guys, but no relationship. In college, she drank a great deal with the sorority-a point of pride to drink guys under the table. She has a masters degree in education, but is a project manager in the telecom industry and has miraculously survived 9 -or more- corporate buyouts with out ever getting laid off.
I am 16 months younger than Middle Sister. I was a 'tom-boy'-loved sports. I recently realized that I was simply born an athlete back when that wasn't the best thing to be born as for a girl-early '60's. I liked the guys in the neighborhood (I wasn't the only girl in the neighborhood that played outside) and could keep up in the games, but I wasn't promiscuous with them (too young at that point). They wouldn't see me that way, I didn't care-oblivious to it-didn't bother me. By high school, my athletics turned to swimming, horseback riding (I rode Older Sister's horse after she lost interest/left) and martial arts -none related to school-and I was still able to maintain top grades in school. I also had a boyfriend from martial arts class for two years, then refused sex and got dumped-true heart break. I was engaged to be married in college, but broke it off as I recognized it was emotionally abusive and I wanted to 'skip the divorce'. I have a masters degree in and a professional license to practice architecture. Got married, and chose to be a full time SAHM (another discussion) have 2dc and one on the way.
So how could parents treat three so completely different girls equally? I think they had a strategy of responding to problems, especially since Older Sister was not shy in creating them. Middle Sister was an 'angel'. So far, the only circumstance I can think of her being 'corrected' was that she was fussed at for not doing her share of the chores. Parents probably lectured her about her weight, but didn't insist on a diet/exercise program, although she was on the swim team for a while. Not a greatly competitive team, but... Mom must have insisted she swim. If they ever said anything to her about her
self-centeredness and they probably did, it was an argument and she probably ended up in her room for a while, but no change. If she ever did volunteer work, it wasn't significant enough for me to remember it. She probably did some with the sorority, but that was probably more identified with the party afterward. If she was forced to do something at someone else's idea or direction as a child, she'd grudgingly do it with a great and dramatic negative attitude.
However, I caught hell simply by association with my Older Sister. We rode horses together, therefor it was presumed that I was destined to suffer influence from her and make bad decisions. I was accused of doing drugs and of being promiscuous -unfair and not true.
I spent time with my Dad on weekends, being his shop or 'farm' assistant in what ever project he was working on. I helped haul a lot of fire wood when he added a wood stove onto the furnace system. I don't remember Middle Sister helping Dad much. She was closer to Mom and spent more time with her than with Dad. I was the opposite. I can't say Middle Sister and I were close growing up, not like I was with Older Sister-through the horses.
I think because I was a tom-boy/athlete, my mother was dismissive towards me in terms of bothering to give much motherly advice, or ballet and piano lessons (I try to be fair: other sisters didn't exactly excel so why waste the resource on the third? Perhaps I was spared the wrath of the clique mean girls and should not hold this in resentment , or Mom's medical bills may have strained the budget at that time -forgiveness.)
She did tell me to wear a dress or skirt twice a week to school, which I did. Hated it because of teasing/harassment, but did it anyway. The teasing stopped after awhile. So, I changed. I remember cooking with Mom and learning to sew some basic things and gardening. So I realize I wasn't ignored across the board- off and on, she taught me stuff that she could and those were loving actions. She wasn't able to teach me social things though. That was the neglect I now feel. While other needs were met, the social piece of the pie is massively significant and so obvious when absent. But enough pieces of the pie were there, in combination with the now known as therapeutic swimming, horseback riding and martial arts activities (where I got my self-esteem), I believe I survived better than would be expected.
In terms of Middle Sister, guidance about self-centeredness was neglected or ineffective perhaps because it was a social skill as well, Mom just couldn't do it.
Sorry this has gone on so long and I realize that if Middle Sister found this and read it, the information here would be telling. Chances are small, non-existent.
However, part of my wall is not to be concerned if 'her toes get stepped on', that card is worn out.
Time for a coffee break lunch. Thanks for your patience.