Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

How to deal with friend who criticises my appearance?

80 replies

stargirl04 · 25/09/2014 21:01

Hi,

I have a friend who I've known for 25 years whose company I enjoy but she is always trying to "improve" me.

On the one hand, I'm going through a tough time at the moment and she's been really concerned and helped in concrete ways.

On the other hand, I met her for lunch today and she asked me if I had ever considered plastic surgery.

I'm almost 49 and well past the first flush of youth but I have come to accept my wrinkles, and if men don't like them, I couldn't care less!

I know I have smokers' lines around my mouth and they do annoy me but that's a problem you can't correct with surgery. I said to her that "some" celebs (though not all) who'd had stuff done to their lips/mouth area end up looking like the Joker in Batman, so I'd "rather keep my wrinkles and age gracefully."

She said: "Did you used to smoke?" and I said, "No, I have never smoked in my life. It's just bad luck."

Then she said: "You should go back to the gym and try to lose weight." I'm a size 16 and have recently started going to the gym, so she said, "But you haven't lost weight. Don't you want to be healthy?"

I said that my weight was nobody else's business and that looking perfect was not everyone's priority. Instead of focusing on their appearance some people might want to study quantum physics or the works of Plato, for example (though not I) and that owing to time constraints, something had to give. Waistlines, perhaps.

She's lost a good few friends over the years, some mutual, and today she told me that those who remain don't call her so often and wondered why.

I am tired of her remarks - as this has gone on years (even when I was thin and smooth skinned!) - and want to tackle it but I'm not sure about the best way to go about it.

First there's the adult approach: I email or text her in the next few days saying that while I value her friendship and the concrete help she's given me in my current difficulty, I find her comments about my appearance hurtful?

However, she will justify it, say she never meant to cause offence and imply that I'm hypersensitive.

Or should I try a different approach and do nothing until the next time I see her, wait for the barbed comment, then say, "Remember when you told me last time we met that some friends never called you? Perhaps this is the reason...." etc

Or should I try the same tactic back and say... "Hmm, given all the exercise you do you do still have a large bottom and I wondered how you felt about that? Would you ever consider a bottom lift?

I risk our friendship, yes, and feel a bit churlish after the way she's helped me with my difficulty (which I don't want to go into), but really don't want this to continue. Even if I had a friend who was 30 stone and looked 100 I would never, ever pass comment about it or bring it up in any way.

Thanks for reading, mumsnetters.

OP posts:
ChelsyHandy · 10/11/2014 16:19

Well, it sounds like you don't like her, so why not just distance yourself? Don't respond or do so vaguely and slowly, always be busy when you want to meet up and if asked why, simply say you don't like being criticised.

Plenty of women do surely want to talk about hair and make up and appearance surely? I know I do with plenty of my female friends - but we try to avoid falling into that trap of thinking middle age = an expanding waistline, and want to remain fit and active, and interested in their appearance.

TheLittleOneSaidRollOver · 10/11/2014 19:47

So what if she goes nuts and gets vindictive?

Just how sensitive is this sensitive info she has got on you?

If a known bitch goes all social media psycho on someone, then nobody will think badly of the someone. Well, nobody that matters.

You might feel better if you make a more assertive stand rather than hiding and hoping.

springydaffs · 11/11/2014 00:17

If you're feeling sensitive that she could blab something personal, it would protect you more to not attack her/point out her faults etc. Perhaps stick to an unemotional 'I don't like it/I want it to stop' rather than 'you do this/that', which is attacking. yy she is attacking as a matter of course but if you attack back it leaves you vulnerable to reprisals.

I also find the 'grade out slowly until they get the hint' just horrible tbh, regardless who it is or what they've done. That said, I've recently realised I have a frenemy and, as a result, there is nothing I want to do with her. I've tried to think of something but, nope, there's nothing. I'm staying friendly eg phone chats sometimes, just not being available to do the things we used to do together - why would I want to spend time with her if she hacks away incessantly. I must be honest I cba to confront her.

MistressDeeCee · 11/11/2014 00:49

She can't be feeling good about herself if she needs to put you down in such a horrible way. Im not surprised she is helping you through tough times - as nice as that can be, given her character she remnds me of people who just love when someone else is having a hard time, and then wants to criticise them when they appear to get back on their feet. Their concern goes out of the window in wanting to drag you back down. To be honest Id tell her exactly how I felt about her remarks, then send her on her way never to be seen again. Maybe you won't want to be direct with her - but maybe also have a think..why do you want/need someone like this as a friend? I'd have got shot of her long ago, I can't be bothered with people like that. No tact or grace. No..it would be a 'get lost' from me. & in terms of revealing personal info about you, whats to say she isn't doing that already? She doesn't sound to have much integrity at all. At the very least, she is aiming to tread on your self-esteem. Good luck however you choose to deal with it

ChickenMe · 11/11/2014 08:21

Take the plunge OP and ignore her from now on. It is hard but once you've done it that first time it becomes easier.
Your frenemy sounds like one I had (and ditched). I think she loved to make other people look small. I always felt infantile around her. Plus she was an appearance criticiser-eg laughing out loud (in front of people) at an outfit I wore, very angry when I lost a lot of weight. Also, she knew absolutely everything. And could never be wrong or show any weakness. Thing is she is fat, acts like a steamroller and looks like Gerard Depardieu. But apparently everyone fancied her Shock. One day I was honest with myself about her and never spoke to her again.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread