IWBF - I have read your posts with interest as my Dsis is in a similar position to you - she has just re-united with her partner after them splitting due to EA/his behaviour. Here are my opinions (if you want them
)
I went through my big things (emotional side, relationship with the kids) he told me his issues (wants more time for us, wants to come in from work and not have people here - he means my friends and family) - why? are your family that bad? are they horrible to him? are they at yours all the time? - or does he just want to alienate you from them so he can have more control?
1. Am I totally deluding myself that this man I have here now can stay like this? Yes - nobody can change there whole personality - parts of it, yes, but you cant change who you essentially are. I would love (in my DSis case also) to be wrong on this but thats what I believe.
2. Because I like to think methodically, at the moment I think we have about a 70% - 30% against, chance of this working, is 30% large enough odds to take the risk. (I would be interested in your odds based on experience/knowledge) I dont look at it like that - i think it will work while he tries IYSWIM - but as mentioned above you cant change EVERYTHING and cracks will begin to show - may be in 12 months, 18 months or more but they will appear (IMO)
3. In the Lundy book it mentions listening to family members - all my family think he wont/cant change, although they have been supportive of me, they have made it clear what they think about him,can they all be wrong? - No
4. Do you think this is the hoover manourvre (sp)? If so when will I know as I have never seen this level of aparant change - I don't know what this is so can't comment
5. Should I still have a plan in my head incase it goes tits up or will this subconsciously give me a negative outlook and it will fail anyway? - Hmmm.. I want to say yes (cos I want my DSis to have one) BUT if you are serious about trying then you cant because you will be analysing every minute you spend together. However, I would have a 'line' that if crossed it would be the complete end (e.g. unreasonable behaviour to any DC's etc)
I think the family comments he has made to you ring warning bells to me - probably because of the situation I am in with my Dsis - she announced that as he has compromised/changed on so many points, she was prepared to reduce the time spent with her friends and family - it felt like a kick in the face for me to be honest because it was mainly aimed at me & that he had manipulated her quite cleverly. That said - its not about me and if thats what she needs to do to make a go of it then so be it. I will (and do) support her completely.
Sorry if i've banged on about my DSIS a lot - please DO NOT alienate yourself from friends and family & i wish you the very best of luck. I will watch this thread closely so please keep posting! x