I'm sure there will be lots of these posts today! We just found out that DS has a place at his second choice school (which we will accept). We were, however, astonished not to get an offer for his first choice.
His first choice school is a Catholic primary school and DS is Catholic (all forms done by the priest and handed in on time in person). The school is linked to the church he goes to. There are c.40 places a year and for the last few years, there have been c.10 places for Catholic siblings, c.20 places for practicing Catholics in the diocese (the group we fall into) and the other 10 have gone to other Christian denominations.
That's been the latter for many years and we would have comfortably got in. We'd also been told that the school had less applications this year as many EU families had left the area and gone home.
In and of itself, I'm not sure that would be grounds for appeal but a couple of weeks ago, we had a letter from the school offering DS a place for the nursery school attached to it in Sept 2023 (ie not reception). We emailed them to clarify but never got a response as to why we'd been offered this when we'd applied for a Reception place through the system. We had, however, included within our supplement information a letter saying that we were/are considering deferring as DS is an August baby however we'd make the decision one places had been allocated and that we were applying for Reception entry - this is what we were told to do by our local council (and if we decide to defer, DS will stay at his current different nursery).
It seems to me like they've messed up somewhere. Does anyone else agree? I just can't see that they will have had 40 applications that rank above us given we're in one of the highest categories.
Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.
Primary education
Does this sound like the school messed up?
mynameiscalypso · 17/04/2023 18:01
Elsie20 · 17/04/2023 18:22
Sorry i think I've misread that, you mean in previous year?
it sounds like this year more practising Catholics.
PuttingDownRoots · 17/04/2023 18:26
You should be able to find out what category your are in, and what category they offered to. If you think you were placed in the wrong category appeal.
mynameiscalypso · 17/04/2023 18:34
Yea, sorry, I may not have been clear. In previous years, there have never been enough Catholic children to fill all the spaces so have gone down to the 'lower' categories of other Christian children. As a Catholic family (well, not me but that's not important for the purposes!), we should have priority along with other Catholic children who applied. I'd be amazed if there had been a huge influx of Catholic children that the priest wasn't aware of but that's the only explanation if they didn't mess up.
Elsie20 · 17/04/2023 18:22
Sorry i think I've misread that, you mean in previous year?
it sounds like this year more practising Catholics.
PatChaunceysFruitCake · 17/04/2023 18:45
The local authority where I live (and many are the same) publish the allocation data on their website on offer day. You can see the lowest admission criteria applied to applications for a particular school and if relevant the distance of the last child admitted.
Can you have a look at see if you can access this data?
BeautifulWar · 17/04/2023 18:50
Some years the number of sibling applicants is really large compared to other years and trumps everything except cared for children.
Always worth asking though!
Elsie20 · 17/04/2023 18:20
Does this school give priority to other Christian's over Catholics? Eg why are they giving 10 spaces to other Christians. Most Catholic schools I know always prioritise Catholics over any other religion.
it does seem strange
Soontobe60 · 17/04/2023 18:53
You do know that Catholicism is a branch of Christianity don’t you?
Elsie20 · 17/04/2023 18:20
Does this school give priority to other Christian's over Catholics? Eg why are they giving 10 spaces to other Christians. Most Catholic schools I know always prioritise Catholics over any other religion.
it does seem strange
Soontobe60 · 17/04/2023 18:53
You do know that Catholicism is a branch of Christianity don’t you?
Elsie20 · 17/04/2023 18:20
Does this school give priority to other Christian's over Catholics? Eg why are they giving 10 spaces to other Christians. Most Catholic schools I know always prioritise Catholics over any other religion.
it does seem strange
Poster used the phrase 'other Christians' so it's clear the poster knows this. 
Treacletoots · 17/04/2023 18:56
We missed out on our first choice because the local authority systems that were supposed to talk to each other ( Cross County applocation) didn't. Our first choice was never requested by the 'state of the art' computer systems and defaulted to our 2nd choice.
It took about 2 weeks solid on the phone to get them to admit they'd fucked up. And another 2 months to get confirmation we actually had the place despite the school being under subscribed.
Absolute nightmare. Wishing you all the best of luck for dealing with the admissions teams. 😩
Rosecoffeecup · 17/04/2023 19:55
How odd. Presumably he's been offered a place in Reception at your second choice (not nursery), which would suggest the LA is aware of the entry you are applying for?
Sorry I have nothing to add of any benefit, but I hope you get an answer
BendingSpoons · 17/04/2023 20:19
It does sound like the school have categorised him as the year below based on you saying you might defer. Out of interest, if you do defer, would you keep your place or have to reapply?
niclw · 17/04/2023 20:26
Just to throw another idea in the mix. Parents can apply to defer the place. However, many schools don't accept deferrals. Schools have no obligation to do so. Therefore it may be that they won't accept you because your want to defer your child's place.
Don’t want to miss threads like this?
Weekly
Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!
Log in to update your newsletter preferences.
You've subscribed!
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.