Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Pregnancy

Talk about every stage of pregnancy, from early symptoms to preparing for birth.

would you have amnio if nuchal was 1:27000

68 replies

beeny · 07/10/2008 15:57

I am 38 and have one ds who is two.I just wanted some advice

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
10krunner · 07/10/2008 15:58

why would you? They are brilliant odds. Mine was 1:26. Relax and enjoy the rest of your pregnancy.

mumblechum · 07/10/2008 15:58

What does your obstetrician recommend?

Would have thought that as the risk of miscarriage is 1:100 you shouldn't have the amnio.

NatalieJaneIsPregnantAgain · 07/10/2008 15:58

1:27000 think mine was 1:1300 and I didn't even think about an amnio.

Me, personally, no.

mehgalegs · 07/10/2008 15:58

No

Aliensloveunderpants · 07/10/2008 15:59

No, as others have said why would you?

Flamebat · 07/10/2008 15:59

No.

I probably wouldn't have the amnio anyway though

beeny · 07/10/2008 16:00

Thanks i think i just find pregnancy very difficult and dont relax.

OP posts:
JodieG1 · 07/10/2008 16:00

No I wouldn't. The odds of losing the baby after an amnio are much higher than the odds you gave from your nuchal.

Wags · 07/10/2008 16:00

Personally no, but its not about what anyone else does but want you want to do. I was 41 and mine was 1:74. I did have a CVS. What you need to find out is the risk of miscarriage from having an amnio. You will find that the chance of having a miscarriage is far, far higher than there being any chance of the baby having problems. I would guess that the hospital may think its odd to go ahead with more tests when the risk is so low but again its your choice I guess.

billysitch · 07/10/2008 16:01

NEVER WOULD

billysitch · 07/10/2008 16:02

Your decision tho', sorry meant to add that last time.

beeny · 07/10/2008 16:03

Again thanks everyone i need to relax.

OP posts:
detoxdiva · 07/10/2008 16:04

No!

Mine were 1:12000 and was told that's about as good as it gets, so yours are fabulous odds.

It wouldn't even enter my head to test more after odds like that - relax and enjoy your pg

KerryMumchingOnEyeballs · 07/10/2008 16:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

bikerunski · 07/10/2008 16:05

Agree with mumblechum. I am 37,risk from triple test was 1:10000. Didn't give amnio a second thought. ds (a month today) is fine.

beeny · 07/10/2008 16:07

Kerry do you think you should have had amnios to make pregnancy easier

OP posts:
belgo · 07/10/2008 16:08

I don't see why an amnio would make you feel better in this case, as someone else has said, there is a far higher risk from the amnio itself then from odds of 1:27000

No1GruffaloHunter · 07/10/2008 16:10

I think having an Amnio would worry me far more...1% + chance of miscarriage (BTW I'm 39 and my odds were 1 in 883 with this pregnancy).

Life isn't certain and even if you ruled out what could be tested for there are many things that can't be picked up... I hate being out of control but thats pregnancy and motherhood.

KerryMumchingOnEyeballs · 07/10/2008 16:11

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CoteDAzur · 07/10/2008 16:11

The result of a nuchal test is in millimeters, not in 1/10000s, and is not a function of anything else (i.e. not something to be adjusted wrt blood test results) and hence should have a risk assessment in and of itself.

At age 38, personally I would have the amnio no matter what blood tests say.

RibenaBerry · 07/10/2008 16:20

Would it help to visualise what one in 27,000 actually looks like? It means that, if every seat in Wembley Stadium (90,000 seats) had a baby sitting in it, your risk means that roughly three of them would have Downs.

On the other hand, if the mother had an amnio for each one of those babies, roughly 900 of them would have been lost to miscarriage.

I am not trying to knock having the amnio test. It is most definitely the best thing for some people. However, I also feel that those big abstract statistics don't always help you to process the numbers.

Does that help at all?

CoteDAzur · 07/10/2008 16:21

Check with your hospital how many miscarriages they have had after amnio over the years. It doesn't have to conform to the 0.5% figure of 30 years ago, nor the "1%" figure routinely quoted on MN but is far from reality.

When I was pregnant with DD, I found out that in the ten years since this same doctor has been doing amnios there, he has had only one miscarriage and that was a 42 year old woman with other problems in pregnancy. That was 3 years ago and when I asked again recently (6 weeks pregnant these days) I found out that there hasn't been another miscarriage since.

A recent study, led by Keith Eddleman, MD, of
New York's Mt. Sinai School of Medicine, and published in the November issue of Obstetrics & Gynecology, sought to determine if amniocentesis still has the 0.5% miscarriage rate (one in 200 pregnancies) that it did 30 years ago, when the last significant research was done. Dr. Eddleman offered amniocentesis to 35,000 pregnant women; 3,000 women opted to have it performed and the outcome was the same for both those who had the test and those who didn't -- about 1% of the women in both groups miscarried.

In this study the amniocentesis-related miscarriage rate was 0.06%, or one in 1,600 pregnancies -- significantly lower than the 0.5% rate that came out of studies performed in the 1970s. Since then, there have been many innovations in amniocentesis safety, the most significant being the use of ultrasound technology during the procedure - doctors are able to view the baby and therefore determine where to insert the needle.

From here

CS7 · 07/10/2008 16:45

Absolutely not.

jujumaman · 07/10/2008 16:51

Certainly not
Those are excellent odds
Amnios are not 100 per cent reliable in any case

jujumaman · 07/10/2008 16:54

btw though beeny I see where you're coming from, I had similar odds I think in my last pg and still fretted about this a lot. But I didn't and in hindsight I realise pregnancy does turn us a bit weird, preparation for motherhood. Good luck whatever you decide

Swipe left for the next trending thread