ds wasn't traumatic as such, but was induced in hospital, with VERY incompetent student mw overseeing it (she failed to notice I was actually in labour at the time) - best quote from her, when I said I'd like to go to the delivery suite was 'they're very busy, you're not in labour yet dear - I'll just see how you're getting on - OH MY GOD YOU'RE 7 cm,' just after saying 'the last baby I induced was born in the toilet on the ward'), I had epidural, ds got into distress, they started murmuring C-section, did fetal blood samples (not pleasant experience), machine to analyse them broke, had to do it again, junior doctor couldn't get blood to come out of ds' head, finally managed sample, all fine, ds born after 13 hours labour. 2nd degree tear, lots of stitches. Then whisked off to 'nursery' because was a bit mucousy, I was whisked off to ward with no dh, no baby. Ds took ages to learn to feed, ended up mixed feeding him because he wouldn't put on any weight.
Dd - went into labour about 6.30 in morning, having told consultant didn't want to be induced (she was very late also), mw arrived about 9.30, 10cm dilated, 2nd mw arrived 10.00, dd born 10.10, no stitches, no pain relief (just wasn't time), dd over 10lbs, mws had all gone by 10.30, and it was all lovely. Dd fed beautifully, did everything she was supposed to.
No comparison in my view. The notes from the 2 books are interesting to compare - there are 6 pages from ds' birth, half a page from dds.